Quote from Shirak:
Can't help but add on to this discussion.
IMO, in order to be a profitable trader, a person should be able to NOT USE STOPS.
But that statement itself is superficial and does not expand much. There is something deeper.
What I mean by this is that, a trader should be trading such a small size that he can withstand anywhere between 2X to 5X ATR of losses.
Of course, this must be coupled with a frame work of knowing when to exit positions.
This being said, I totally agree that either big accounts or small contracts i.e. mini-micro FX are required in order for people to trade profitability.
For me, my "soft" stops are often 2X ATR risking 3% of my capital. But >80% of the time, I'm out at 1%, that's the "real" stop. So everytime I trade, I'm relaxed as hell. The whole philosophy is, trade sizes where you need not be bothered about where your stop is, just a rough knowledge of where to get out is enough.
Logically, traders risking 5% per trade with stops can make it in the short run, but can you imagine continuously doing it all the time? After 20 trades, your psychological state goes awry and you start making mistakes and poof, there goes your account.
I do not profess profound knowledge and my opinions are merely opinions. I am merely sharing what I learnt over the years.