Originally posted by NihabaAshi
hmap1,
This is my personal view about trading systems or mechanical systems.
If I were using one and it has amazing profits. I would not start a forum thread on the subject nor reveal the fact that I was using such.
Simply, if it's such a well kept secret via you saying..."we are not permitted" and "we don't want to jeapordize the revenue"...
why would you want to reveal the fact that you have such a secret?
I think all traders that are trading successfully for a living regardless if its via mechanical or discretionary feel they know something that the other guy/gal doesn't know...
or they feel they know what the other guy/gal knows but their much more efficient than the other person...in reference to discretionary traders.
With that said...if I had a successful mechanical system that was the life blood of the company I work at or the life blood of my family financial well-being...
you'll never see me mentioning it here at EliteTrader nor at any other discussion boards.
Now...if I was a retired trader and wanted to market a successful mechanical system knowing it will no longer affect me because I'm no longer putting money on trade positions...that's an entire different subject.
By the way, are successful mechancial systems usually sold to someone or are they developed by someone at a company or by an individual...and it's never marketed?
Also, if it's sold to a company or individual...would there be some legal contract that stated it can never be shared with someone else?
If such legal contracts are not the norm...wouldn't mechanical systems of such be jeopardize in their reliability.
Maybe someone with a lawyer background or corporate law could better answer such a question.
I brought this up because a guy I know (software engineer) designed something for a networking company that will make them more efficient and save their clients millions.
He quit over another unrelated issue...now works for another networking company and his previous employer is suing to prevent him from sharing what he knows with the new boss.
My analogy is this...isn't it the norm to have legal agreements between system developers or users not to share such info with someone else because it will or could affect their profits?
I apologize if I take this thread in another direction...couldn't resist.
Nihaba Ashi