Trading Flow technique by McRibel.com

Is Trading Flow a new idea?

  • New idea

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Old idea

    Votes: 4 100.0%
  • Total voters
    4
O

ozzie_bozo

Seeking opinions on McRibel.com's "Trading Flow" approach (as contrasted to money flow).

Is this old hat? Is it an old approach with a new name? Or is it novel?

All input appreciated. (I was unable to get any info on Elite Trader by searching for "McRibel" and for "Trading Flow".)

Here's the link:

http://mcribel.com/handbook/appendix1.htm
 
Interesting.

Doing it that way seems like it would take a BOATLOAD more data than classic money flow. Not only do you need tick data, but also bid and ask.

And how do they take into account trades that go off outside the NBBO (people getting screwed or negotiated trades)?
 
Thank you much for your feedback, Cash. Given your position with Bright Trading, I know your impressions are based on a LOT of experience.
 
This kind of indicator has been 'introduced' some months ago in the Active Trader Magazine. There they called it 'Cumulative Volume Delta (CVD)'. Maybe you can find there additional information.

The problem is the data you need for the calculation. As cashonly already mentioned you need to know for every tick whether it was at the bid or ask price.

Tradestation for example is not able to gather this information.
 
Quote from mujoh:

This kind of indicator has been 'introduced' some months ago in the Active Trader Magazine. There they called it 'Cumulative Volume Delta (CVD)'. Maybe you can find there additional information.

The problem is the data you need for the calculation. As cashonly already mentioned you need to know for every tick whether it was at the bid or ask price.

Tradestation for example is not able to gather this information.
More...

CVD was actually developed at TT an is available in XStudy (the free charting package that was just released with xtrader 7.0)

XStudy collects the bid/ask info required.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top