Trading education

Quote from bone:

So, at least in Chicago, there are a handful of firms that hire very select graduates from very select academic backgrounds. But other than that, you really have to sell them with a methodology that they think makes sense - and they have been pitched on everything.

Agreed, with the right educational background there are some large companies that will hire you and treat you right, however, as you may or may not know, most wannabe traders lack this qualification and they believe they can run a marathon barefoot, they have the spirit, but lack the fundamentals. Their ignorance blinds them. They want to play hardball with the pros not really understanding how easy it is to lose money in this business.
 
Quote from bloomberg:

Another winner here!!! Who sold you people this idea that there are firms out there waiting with their arms open to make you rich?

Some prop firms make money, yes, but they also LOSE money, LOTS of it, on their recommendations. If you don't know what you're doing you will blow your account in just a couple of bad streaks.

OTA is not the only answer, it was mentioned and spoken about because this is what the thread is about, there are books and other sources you can get your education from, if books and videos is your style more power to you!

But knowing what I know now I would NOT start off at a prop firm without any education. How much education is enough to make money should be the real question.

Sim trading and real money trading are two very different animals.

Who said they were waiting with open arms to make us rich? Those are your words, not mine.

There is a high failure rate in trading at a retail and also at a professional level, however, professional traders have a much better success ratio than those who try to go it alone at home with limited resources.

That's all I'm saying. If you go it alone you are basically guaranteed to fail. If you seek out people who are making money and have been doing so for years, then you have a fighting chance if you are able to follow direction.
 
I learned from sitting right beside the owner/head trader of a prop firm. In the 2 years I was there, the blowout rate ranged from 50%-70%. So a prop firm is no guarantee, but finding the right training drastically improves your chances of success.
 
Quote from ajtixs:

So you are clearly anti-prop, but what about all the successful traders that have come out of prop firms in NYC and CHI??? We should ignore that and just buy a seminar??? Your views are obviously biased and not objective

Not anti-prop, you misunderstand.

Prop firm trading will give you both leverage, and put you past the PDT rule which is great if you don't have the 25k to begin. Also it will allow you to put your money where your mouth is, before you saved the 25k. That's the good part.


However, you cannot ignore the fact that even "market experts" are wrong a lot of times. If you decide to follow someone's trades, and they happen to have a bad streak during that time, you're toast. The way you protect yourself is by learning on your own first. Be it OTA, borders, wikipedia, ET, google whatever tickles your fancy.

Also, and this is important, make sure you know ALL of their fees and find out if your money is tied up with them for a year or so. Some prop firms are dishonest and good luck suing them, not talking from experience here but I heard a few horror stories.

I agree the best way to learn is by surrounding yourself with people that know what they are doing, but if you don't have an understanding of the big picture, which you can only get by education, no-one is going to hold your hand and change your diapers.

I say OTA is good because that has been my experience there, but there are hundreds of other places to choose from.
 
Quote from FXPimp:

the blowout rate ranged from 50%-70%. So a prop firm is no guarantee, but finding the right training drastically improves your chances of success.

That's what Im saying, Im sure those 70% also sat next to someone with experience and probably followed the same trades you did, but they lacked the general understanding and discipline needed to not blow their account.
 
Quote from bloomberg:

You got me there Sherlock, must be a shill because he actually have something GOOD to say about a company. Really, with that rationale I don't know how you can even afford a computer to write your nonsense.

It's funny, when companies get bashed here on ET everyone joins in, but when there is something good to say about any company it's a shill.

What's interesting about this particular company is that it's only the people who have NOT tried OTA that bash it, not sure if that's the case for other companies mentioned here on ET.

Sorry, but I went to an OTA "seminar" and posted a review of it here already on ET.

It is manure. After the pitch, the "counsellor" violated several laws trying to sell me, and made obviously shaky claims. I almost turned them in. Only a CTA could ask me some of the questions he did.

They flood the web with shill "independent reviews" including on Youtube. You sound almost EXACTLY like the 4-5 hour pitch and their shill reviews.

It is an overpriced TA lesson - Gaps and other stuff you can get for free on the web, and the claims of allowing you to "trade their money" is in fact tiny amounts, which they do not bother to mention.

I managed to talk one person out of buying, but another went for it hook, line and sinker

And their "$6,000 CDs" are avilable for a few hundred on EBay.

One of the most blatantly hyped "promise" companies in the trading world, along with TMTT, and a few others.

 
Quote from TraderZones:

Sorry, but I went to an OTA "seminar" and posted a review of it here already on ET.

It is manure. After the pitch, the "counsellor" violated several laws trying to sell me, and made obviously shaky claims. I almost turned them in. Only a CTA could ask me some of the questions he did.

They flood the web with shill "independent reviews" including on Youtube. You sound almost EXACTLY like the 4-5 hour pitch and their shill reviews.

It is an overpriced TA lesson - Gaps and other stuff you can get for free on the web, and the claims of allowing you to "trade their money" is in fact tiny amounts, which they do not bother to mention.

I managed to talk one person out of buying, but another went for it hook, line and sinker

And their "$6,000 CDs" are avilable for a few hundred on EBay.

One of the most blatantly hyped "promise" companies in the trading world, along with TMTT, and a few others.


Exactly my point, you went to the seminar not the actual class, and all of a sudden you're the expert.

No-one is glorifying their "counselors", they're salesmen trying to make commissions, just like your favorite prop firm. If they broke the law then sue them. Also, if you're so sensitive about someone selling you something then why go to a seminar? Says a lot about your judgement.

Come on, just say it, you couldn't afford the class so you're pissed off because they blew you off and didn't give you the ridiculous discount you asked for. That must have hurt.
 
Quote from bloomberg:

Exactly my point, you went to the seminar not the actual class, and all of a sudden you're the expert.

No-one is glorifying their "counselors", they're salesmen trying to make commissions, just like your favorite prop firm. If they broke the law then sue them. Also, if you're so sensitive about someone selling you something then why go to a seminar? Says a lot about your judgement.

Come on, just say it, you couldn't afford the class so you're pissed off because they blew you off and didn't give you the ridiculous discount you asked for. That must have hurt.

Nice try changing the subject. The only one who would get so defensive about a course is a shill.

And you question why someone would go to a seminar and then realize that it was just a come-on - a glorified TA course for $6,000??? Because I have traded far longer than yourself, and it did not take long to realize what they were trying to pull off.

But ignoring you and your pathetic attempts to look disinterested, and for those planning to make a mistake by chasing after OTA or other worthless courses,

EBay --> "online trading academy" You can get their stuff for $200-$300. And that is likely more than it is worth, as it is a rehash of trading books and free stuff on the internet and on ET. But $6,000? do some reviews, ignore the 5-star OTA plants and you will start to realize you will get no edge there
 
Back
Top