Trading Advantage: Institutional vs Retail

W

Woodrow97

What do you guys think some of the advantages are for both institutional and retail traders?

Here's my two cents:

Institutional -
1. Technology. ex. Renaissance supercomputers
2. Order flow. ex. MMs doing conversions and reversals.
3. Portfolio margin. Less collateral needed for hedges; M&A arbitrage; etc.

Retail -
1. Low, fixed commissions.
2. Liquidity. Trading any security one wants and getting filled at the exact price.

Feel free to add more to the list.
 
Institutional has exposure to more liquidity
As mentioned - economies of scale in technology-Quant and AI talent
OTC and unique structures in derivatives.
Institutional pays higher commissions(generally) as the price for upstairs liquidity.
Generous stock loan.
Overall trade friction can be lower overall
Never wait on the phone.
Some Dark Pool data on the desk.
Often more avenues for research and ideas.
Mixed bag on compliance and market regulation.
Mixed bag on reputation issues as well.
Better access to Algos.
 
Woodrow97 said:
What do you guys think some of the advantages are for both institutional and retail traders?

Here's my two cents:

Institutional -
1. Technology. ex. Renaissance supercomputers
2. Order flow. ex. MMs doing conversions and reversals.
3. Portfolio margin. Less collateral needed for hedges; M&A arbitrage; etc.

Retail -
1. Low, fixed commissions.
2. Liquidity. Trading any security one wants and getting filled at the exact price.

Feel free to add more to the list.
More...

Institutions are like elephants. It will take them a while, to unload or buy millions of shares for instance. It is harder for them to put up huge numbers like 100% in returns or more in a short period of time. Institutions would be happy with 10-15% per annum.
Retail traders can easily sell their shares and get out and get into a new position. The one advantage retail traders have is speed and the ability to take advantage of opportunity wherever that is! Institutions take time to establish their huge positions over a span of 3-6 months depending on how many millions of shares they are buying or selling.
 
Added to the list.
Woodrow97 said:
Institutional -
1. Technology. ex. Renaissance supercomputers
2. Order flow. ex. MMs doing conversions and reversals.
3. Portfolio margin. Less collateral needed for hedges; M&A arbitrage; etc.
4. Access to structured products
5. Access to all sorts of markets outside the US

Retail -
1. Low, fixed commissions.
2. Liquidity. Trading any security one wants and getting filled at the exact price.
3. Lack of restrictive mandate
4. Lack of artificial risk management metrics
5. No minimum capacity requuirement
More...

You would be suprised, but retail advantages are a huge deal. I have, more than once, said that a retail trader can easily make really good returns on a small amount of capital simply due to his structural advantages.
 
"Women are like elephants. I like to look at 'em, but I wouldn't want to own one." W. C. Fields
My HR department would want me to qualify this quote as sexist and not supported by the firm.
 
TheBigShort said:
Would you not say it still takes alot of talent/work and much time out of your day, to find and monitor these structural trades?
More...
Well, yes. It's much easier to climb a Mt. Ranier then it is to climb K2, but it's still hard work.
 
If we asked for the structure - we had a reason. It's also a matter of good technology. The challenge isn't always about monitoring - we joke that that is why they call it work. Sometimes we also see opportunities in the listed we can trade around the structure we own.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top