Quote from JohnnyK:
jem,
is it true the Catholic church has, since 1972 declined in membership by half? does anyone have numbers on this?
JohnnyK
I have seen people attempt to synthesize numbers based on incomplete data. I have not seen any studies that can give an accurate tally the situation. It is really very difficult to count Catholics in the States. Catholics are much more lax on figuring out who is in their congregation relative to the Protestant Churches in my experience. There are structural reasons for this. It is easier to switch from one Protestant denomination to another. Frequently it involves an altar call and ensuring a proper baptism in your past. It is much more difficult to become a Catholic and go to Communion which is the focus of the Mass. The Chruch is rarely if ever in the back tallying its members.
Catholic chruches are setup differently. First of all many Catholics do not even register with one Parish. Catholics frequently go to numerous different chruches in their area depending on the schedule.
So while their may be some indication that the Chruch has lost members especially in Europe accurate counts in the States are probably non existent. However, if my observation counts for anything, Catholic Churches I have visted are full with people standing at multiple different Masses on Sundays.
I would be surprised if the numbers of Catholics attending Mass was dwindling. I know that after the Priest scandal, there was a decrease in participation but I think that was a temporary blip. I also note that there is a baby boom in suburban Catholic Chruches.