joey, your points are well taken as it is a MUST to be a skeptic in this industry as there are many, who will do anything to make a dime. yet, i think the benefit of this thread is not for traders to post how great they are as traders because they make X amount of money, each and everyday, BUT rather to inspire, share a few PMs, and motivate others to see what can be monetarily done as a trader.
when i started out trading in 2000 at ECHO, I was able to see guys in the office that made good, good money day in and day out for a couple years. it was amazing to see their numbers at the end of everyday - +2500 to +4000 ... each and every darn day ... for 2 years.
this was very important for me to see because I knew that guys were making great money trading, and that it was possible to make that money on a daily / consistent fashion.
IF anything, this thread demonstrates and shows newbies/unsuccessful traders the potential for what guys are able to do daily. And, if for some reason these p / l sheets are fake, so what...
because there are traders making great money day in and day out. It can be done, it is being done and you can be motivated by it and by this thread.
PatrickQ