...As mentioned, I liked the thread and her journal, but when she offered to explain her fib setup I took the offer and wanted her to explain, she did not...
You may be fine to go by someone's predictons (otherwise why would that be fine enough for you?) but most serious traders do their own work. When they check out others ideas then its to possibly add value to their trading not to copy or emulate someones ideas. When she was asked by someone else earlier how the indicators she uses as part of that "top gun" package work she mentioned she did not know. Its all good for her as long as she makes money, but again, let me ask you a serious question: What value do you yourself derive from some posted numbers and levels that the poster is unwilling or unable to explain?
I dont try to bash Amy but wanted to learn something, I dont learn by someone posting some numbers and suggested to her to shed some light into the whole thing to enrich the experience for all. I am sure Amy is mature and confident enough to state her opinions, no need for some *cabletrader* with a girl-protection-complex to jump in. By the way, check out cabletrader's other comments in other fx threads, he obviously has got no clue of trading, I proved him wrong several times because he gave out wrong information to others, no wonder he has got an axe to grind....;-)
You may be fine to go by someone's predictons (otherwise why would that be fine enough for you?) but most serious traders do their own work. When they check out others ideas then its to possibly add value to their trading not to copy or emulate someones ideas. When she was asked by someone else earlier how the indicators she uses as part of that "top gun" package work she mentioned she did not know. Its all good for her as long as she makes money, but again, let me ask you a serious question: What value do you yourself derive from some posted numbers and levels that the poster is unwilling or unable to explain?
I dont try to bash Amy but wanted to learn something, I dont learn by someone posting some numbers and suggested to her to shed some light into the whole thing to enrich the experience for all. I am sure Amy is mature and confident enough to state her opinions, no need for some *cabletrader* with a girl-protection-complex to jump in. By the way, check out cabletrader's other comments in other fx threads, he obviously has got no clue of trading, I proved him wrong several times because he gave out wrong information to others, no wonder he has got an axe to grind....;-)
Quote from JB3:
She can post what she wants on her journal. It's not a training offer. If you don't believe her, then just find the next thread to read. And if Fib works for her, and not you, so be it. I don't see why she has to convince you that it works or not.
She is adding value by just posting her predictions and what her system is telling her. She is sharing it with the readers, and I for one, like to read it instead of trying to question or bait someone into trying to reveal their system.