I read him for awhile back in November and December, but basically stopped back in early December when it went to a subscriber basis...I felt it was pretty good at gauging market sentiment in a "loose" and "macro" sense, but as far as being in touch with the short term, or "micro" flows it was a bit counter-trend...Nothing wrong with that, but my impression is that Todd is basically consistently fading the micro to position on the macro...I know of several others who trade in a similar style and its more of a "fund" type approach, where they will endure short term pain to try and "position" for the eventual retracement back...
The only real comment I have about Todd's timing is that since he is essentially positioning on the macro, its a bit misleading to say that he nails tops and bottoms...In due time, of course, he does nail them the majority of the time...But one should also consider that he often will hold a "fractional" position counter to the micro trend for days at a time, averaging in as price moves against him...Therefore when it reverses, it would be safe to assume that he does need more room to capture his cost on the retracements...
Readers will remember his comments from November when he was racketing up his exposure throughout November and was probably still short into the eventual swing high on December 2nd...If he had the patience to wait it out, he eventualy recovered his cost, but this is a very macro approach to trading...