Actually...I did not know what we both know now. Simply, you did not make that info available in this thread until
now.
Others have made recommendations or given
specific advice about what route you should take involving technical analysis. A few have spelled it out in detail in a single message post. They are the ones you should then seek constructive criticism considering they seem to be willing to give you specific TA advice although I'm not sure if they are willing to go as far as to give you a complete trading plan for trading stocks.
- Yet, you can always explore how far they are willing to go with you via private message...no harm in trying...right ?
I will say this...there must be a specific reason why you're using RSI, On Balance Volume, Volume, Price Moving Averages and ATR versus using other types of indicators.
Thus, you must have seen value in them versus less value in other indicators. Also, I'm sure you've must have heard by now from others to
backtest those indicators prior to using real money trading. Next, simulate trade to give yourself some clues about your application.
TOS does have a
simulator account...no excuse about why you would skip the simulator to determine if you're profitable via those indicators on a simulator
prior to jumping right into real money trading.
Continuing my recommendation...use ET search function (located in the upper right corner) to find traders using those specific indicators. Share with them the specific details about your trade strategy involving those specific indicators, share with them your broker trade statement with timestamps of trade fills so that they can evaluate how you're using your indicators
versus what you're actually doing in your trading with real money on the line.
You've now share that your stats are
not good but there's still no details about the stats.
Heck, you couldn't / wouldn't even answer the question about the number of trades you've taken so far...5, 10, 50, 100 or what.
Why would I ask such an easy question to answer ? It will show how willing you're able to provide info about something that's so easily available to the trader of the trading account and show how likely you'll withhold other info from those that actually want to help you.
Therefore, share with them the
details about your stats too so that they can determine if the problem is your stats and not your strategy or maybe the problem is not the stats nor the strategy but its
you (your application). If you don't have the stats...get them.
- The big question, maybe mute now...why are you trading with via those indicators if you don't have backtest results to show you have an edge ?
What I'm saying is that their are two critical types of statistics: 1) backtests 2) Actual trading results
If your backtests are poor...you shouldn't be trading. Yet, if your backtests are good but your actual real money trading results stats are poor...the issue is you. The good news...trade strategies can be fixed or adapted. The trader is a more difficult problem to fix if that's the primary problem.
Hopefully the above info is more helpful and I hope you'll use Elitetrader.com search function to find traders (there's many) using those indicators that may willing to help you.
- By the way, I know TOS (thinkorswim) program and they have education info and chat rooms...have you explore that to find someone to help you with those indicators ?
Good luck
wrbtrader