<i>"Turnover, in this example, means guys retiring a series of user names when their credibility is shot and/or they make a bad prediction, etc.
Turnover also implies there are alot of now defunct user names. After all, of the entire number of users registered over the past 8-9 years, a very small percentage of those people still post."</i>
All very true. If each alias here were attached to one person only via credit card verification, etc the number of total "members" would be slashed to something like 1/5th current historical tally.
Why do people quit posting? Many reasons. Some wash out, for sure. Others simply tire of the atmosphere and fade into the background. It was interesting that someone of stature like lescor recently posted actual trade results in P&L 2007 and got flamed for that act. Other guys get deified here while refusing to ever post a single trade blotter that shows actual proof of any live trades, out of sample or otherwise.
It was telling that lescor referenced a private room he and other real-money traders gather in these days instead of this forum. Sounds to me like many - most of the real elite traders are gathering elsewhere.
I pass thru here infrequently myself. The list of topics for the most part miss my areas of interest more & more. Very seldom find a constructive topic to converse in, so there's not much for me to say. Some days I don't even think about logging in, and that seems to be more often lately.
The OP here is feeling good about what was accomplished. Who hasn't turned a net-loss day into net profit and not felt layers of warm emotions about that? This is a grueling, grinding, roller coaster emotional profession. Learning to manage that inner minefield is the biggest learning curve for any of us.
I didn't perceive this thread as boasting... the OP is doing a fine job of learning the ropes. All of us are constantly learning, no exceptions. Actually nice to see a thread about live trading, for a change.