The turtles. Are they real?

Quote from michael c:

Great information, M. Thank You! The turtle system taught on turtletrader seems to be nothing but buy new highs, hold through drawdowns and hope. That is what it seems John Henry and Ed Sexkota do, and they seem to be the patron saints of turtle trading. I mean, it obviously works, if you can hold and spread yourself across enough uncorrelated markets. Unfortunately, the average non millonaire trader would be destroyed trading like this. turtletrading does not seem to address this fact.

Mike C

As opposed to the riches provided by your neo-Gann shit.:)
 
From a post I made a few years back


Pabst


Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 2857


03-27-02 01:26 AM

I'm not the best guy to comment on this. I grew up a scalper and even now off the floor I consider a 2 day position an "investment".
But as someone who has seen the likes of Rich Dennis and Tudor Jones operate, those "5%" winning trades involve add on after add on. Case in point is Dennis in the 1985-1986 bull market in bond futures. He would start with his normal unit of 500 contracts and get chopped for days. Buy the days high, put em back out on a new swing low ect. Every once in a while he'd wind up with 500 that worked. Then he'd start the process higher, all over again. Work em in, work em out. After maybe a couple of months the market has rallied 10pts. from where he started and he has 2000 on.(meaning 2million a point) Now the market is short and ready to pop on any size buying and he's there supplying the noose. Bidding for 500 on every up tick, finally gets to a point where for the last month of the move he has 5000 on. T-Bonds rally 20 pts. in just over a month and he's up $100,000,000 on a trade that started out with him just testing the waters,losing $100,000 a few times before he could establish a position worth doubling up on.
 
Quote from Pabst:

From a post I made a few years back


Pabst


Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 2857


03-27-02 01:26 AM

I'm not the best guy to comment on this. I grew up a scalper and even now off the floor I consider a 2 day position an "investment".
But as someone who has seen the likes of Rich Dennis and Tudor Jones operate, those "5%" winning trades involve add on after add on. Case in point is Dennis in the 1985-1986 bull market in bond futures. He would start with his normal unit of 500 contracts and get chopped for days. Buy the days high, put em back out on a new swing low ect. Every once in a while he'd wind up with 500 that worked. Then he'd start the process higher, all over again. Work em in, work em out. After maybe a couple of months the market has rallied 10pts. from where he started and he has 2000 on.(meaning 2million a point) Now the market is short and ready to pop on any size buying and he's there supplying the noose. Bidding for 500 on every up tick, finally gets to a point where for the last month of the move he has 5000 on. T-Bonds rally 20 pts. in just over a month and he's up $100,000,000 on a trade that started out with him just testing the waters,losing $100,000 a few times before he could establish a position worth doubling up on.

Yes, exactly. This makes perfect sense and will obviously work. How does this relate to turtle trading as taught in Michael Corvel's site? It requires vast sums of capital, vast sums. It is not something an average joe trader could possibly accomplish. Your background is impressive!

Mike
 
Quote from michael c:

Yes, exactly. This makes perfect sense and will obviously work. How does this relate to turtle trading as taught in Michael Corvel's site? It requires vast sums of capital, vast sums. It is not something an average joe trader could possibly accomplish. Your background is impressive!

Mike

RD started with something like 2 grand.
 
Few people have the stomach for that, which says alot about successful traders. Nice post Pabst.




Quote from Pabst:

From a post I made a few years back


Pabst


Registered: Dec 2001
Posts: 2857


03-27-02 01:26 AM

I'm not the best guy to comment on this. I grew up a scalper and even now off the floor I consider a 2 day position an "investment".
But as someone who has seen the likes of Rich Dennis and Tudor Jones operate, those "5%" winning trades involve add on after add on. Case in point is Dennis in the 1985-1986 bull market in bond futures. He would start with his normal unit of 500 contracts and get chopped for days. Buy the days high, put em back out on a new swing low ect. Every once in a while he'd wind up with 500 that worked. Then he'd start the process higher, all over again. Work em in, work em out. After maybe a couple of months the market has rallied 10pts. from where he started and he has 2000 on.(meaning 2million a point) Now the market is short and ready to pop on any size buying and he's there supplying the noose. Bidding for 500 on every up tick, finally gets to a point where for the last month of the move he has 5000 on. T-Bonds rally 20 pts. in just over a month and he's up $100,000,000 on a trade that started out with him just testing the waters,losing $100,000 a few times before he could establish a position worth doubling up on.
 
Quote from michael c:

I have been lurking and reading this site for a long long time. Finally I have a question... I can not find any proof that the original turtles ever even existed. Outside of an offhand comment made by RIchard Dennis in Market Wizards, I can find nothing else about their origin. there is no substaniating evidence about the bet with eckard or anything at all. Is the turtle story nothing but marketing hype??

mike

The soft rock band was real.
 
Quote from Hamlet:

He had a good demographic by using the WSJ for the ad. I doubt he would have had the same results if he placed the ad in the National Enquirer or People.
true. the demographic was people who take money, finance, and work seriously versus those who just admire people who do.
 
Yes they are real......I have worked with one of them(I won't mention any names). The experience was very enlightening, but maybe a good question to ask is. Do you stop your due diligence or research once you learn the techniques of successful traders? It takes the next level to take what you learn and expand on it. I know one thing most of the original turtles(if they are still trading) have moved on to new techniques. The new techniques can range from fractals and shorter time frames, but I know one thing for sure risk and management is the main focus on their new trading ideology.

...Believe me I have moved on...

(please no pms on my trading methodologies...thank you).


:)
 
Quote from F. d'Anconia:

I have three of the originals living in a terrarium here at my house. Sometimes when the market is choppy I tap on the glass and see if they have any insight.

ROTFL
 
Back
Top