The Trouble With Scribbles
- Thread starter Buy1Sell2
- Start date
BS states his actual trade just as he has entered it and is profitable, so has a lot more credibililty than DB who still runs away from any accountability.
It's just ''Long over xxx'' (but if it goes over xxx and chops around or stops him out, he'll claim to never have taken the trade 5 hours later, lol)
Oldest guru trick in the book.
How about actual real time calls, but based on a much longer timeframe?
Then you can have no excuses as to why you refuse to make them, as the odd tick or 2 would be insignificant?
It's just ''Long over xxx'' (but if it goes over xxx and chops around or stops him out, he'll claim to never have taken the trade 5 hours later, lol)
Oldest guru trick in the book.
How about actual real time calls, but based on a much longer timeframe?
Then you can have no excuses as to why you refuse to make them, as the odd tick or 2 would be insignificant?
It took longer than it should have, but it really has become abundantly clear to me that those who aren't happy with how they trade "wear" their failure on their sleeves.
To end up at breakeven after all that lost opportunity?
Sure. Why not?
You still don't get it, do you? It's not a lost opportunity at all in his view.
And that's the problem.
You have yet to explain why it matters so much to you.
Which is fine, imo. What you and he and all those who are attracted to his style of bombast and attack don't get it this: We do not share his view, and we do not appreciate that he continually inserts his view into our journals and acts as though his view is the correct view. I know you have a short memory, romik, but I will remind you that BS started this whole stupid shooting match. You wouldn't even know we existed had BS not started this bay crap.
As well as starting this thread for the sole purpose of showing how inferior the SLA/AMT is to whatever it is that BS does, in spite of the fact that he knows nothing about it (nor do romik nor hitchslap).
Any of these three could reconstruct a standard SLA/AMT trading sequence for the past two months if only they'd take the trouble to learn what they're talking about. Hell, they could even do it using the rules I've been posting. But, they don't. They'd rather troll.
Any of these three could reconstruct a standard SLA/AMT trading sequence for the past two months if only they'd take the trouble to learn what they're talking about. Hell, they could even do it using the rules I've been posting. But, they don't. They'd rather troll.
Because if he can't do it, no one can.
Seriously people, can you just imagine Linda Raschke coming onto a trading forum and demanding P/L's? Or Trader Vic? Or Marty Schwartz? ROTFLMFAO
People who can do this can discuss ideas with one another like any other group of professionals or dedicated amateurs "talking shop." Those who aren't happy with their trading make it plain by the way they post and the way they treat fellow posters. And if one were to go searching back into ET history, some might be surprised by some who used to post here. What isn't at all surprising is that they left this place behind.
Just for the hell of it, here's an ES chart for the past few weeks showing where BS entered. Perhaps those who've read the material (the pdf, not necessarily W's course) would like to try applying it to this timeframe using the hourly interval. Or those who haven't read it can try to apply the rules I posted earlier (#216). If nothing else, it'll give those who are genuinely interested in this the opportunity to do more than sit in the stands and watch the gladiators beat each other up. Might also encourage the trolls to learn something about the subject.
But probably not.
I have always liked bird dogs better than kennel dogs. You know, ones who will get out and hunt for food rather than sit and yelp.
-- "Engine Charlie" Wilson, once Secretary of Defense
But probably not.
I have always liked bird dogs better than kennel dogs. You know, ones who will get out and hunt for food rather than sit and yelp.
-- "Engine Charlie" Wilson, once Secretary of Defense