You demand detailed explanations how and why traders use constant volume and and range bars to consistently trade profitably pretty much every day (with very narrow ranges probably, but not necessarily, being the exception) from Prof Logic, myself, red duke and anyone else who will deign to respond to your absurd obfuscations, but you can't even give a basic explanation on how YOU determine your trade criteria ... AND you aren't profitable?Quote from marketsurfer:
although the size is always relative, it isn't a constant and varies within the parmeter depending on various factors with price action not being one of them. im not sure how else to explain it.
thanks,
surf
Quote from marketsurfer:
Continuing to hold shorts in YM into monday morning, and looking for potential entry into oil.
hung out with Rev Al, ate some good food, smoked the good smoke on top of 666 ...

Quote from Pekelo:
I don't want to break up the lovefest between Surf and Witty, but just for the record, Surf managed to give up another unbooked 200 points, and the position is around +10 after 10 days of holding. Nice holding, but incredibly bad trading....
So could we keep the cheerleading down until and if Surf finally closes the trade in the green?
Oh, and before somebody start to bitch about 20/20 hindsight, I predicted today's rally yesterday and went long in my journal when Surf was nicely up...
So to summarize:
1. Don't cheer as long as the position is open.
2. Don't go against my predictions...
Edit: the position just went red....
Who knows, I sure don't.Quote from marketsurfer:
thank you.
i don't believe that gap will be filled for a long, long time.
regards,
surfer