The Surf Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote from Pekelo:

Good point. On the other hand he seemed to be genuienly depressed after the last loss. Would papertrading effect one so badly??

P.S.: My other question never answered: What is the purpose of this journal?

I don't know about the "genuinely depressed" part. If he were, one would expect him to learn something from it. He hasn't.

As to the purpose of the journal, good question. It does help to explain where all those people come from who spend fortunes on useless books, seminars, courses, software, etc.

LC
 
Quote from Lamont_C:

I don't know about the "genuinely depressed" part. If he were, one would expect him to learn something from it. He hasn't.

As to the purpose of the journal, good question. It does help to explain where all those people come from who spend fortunes on useless books, seminars, courses, software, etc.

LC

OK, I know why Pekelo is here, but this explains your presence.

JJ
 
Quote from JimmyJam:

OK, I know why Pekelo is here, but this explains your presence.

JJ

Sorry, no. It's an accident by the side of the road, and I'm just as fascinated as anybody.

LC
 
Quote from Pekelo:

Good point. On the other hand he seemed to be genuienly depressed after the last loss. Would papertrading effect one so badly??

P.S.: My other question never answered: What is the purpose of this journal?


purpose??? a log of my trading development---good, bad and ugly. what other purpose would you suspect??

surf:confused:
 
continuing to hold the YM shorts with losses as of today.

please note--our trades are sized based on total portfolio size and are designed to take heat as its impossible to time the market exactly. hopefully this answers the apparent confusion evident.

surf
 
Exactly. It's like watching the Jets on broadcast television.

Quote from marketsurfer:

purpose??? a log of my trading development---good, bad and ugly. what other purpose would you suspect??

surf:confused:
 
Quote from marketsurfer:

continuing to hold the YM shorts with losses as of today.

please note--our trades are sized based on total portfolio size and are designed to take heat as its impossible to time the market exactly. hopefully this answers the apparent confusion evident.

surf

Why have you chosen YM over ES?
 
Surf, you know I like you, but:

Quote from marketsurfer:

a log of my trading development---good, bad and ugly. what other purpose would you suspect??

Well, the problem is, there is no development, quite the opposite. I know in the last few years the journal had been profitable, not so much this year, although I don't really see any big change in the market enviroment. So what gives?

The most dangerous is that you don't seem to be LEARNING or LISTENING to advice. The best example is the FOMC tomorrow. Last time you went into the FOMC with a position already in the red and then you got rammed so bad, that you took a sabbatical after that from trading.

Then here comes this FOMC and guess what? You are going into it with a position with an even BIGGER loss already. Something just never changes....

Sure, you can get lucky this time, and the market might sell off tomorrow, but that is not trading, and certainly not money management. If you really wanted to short so badly, why did you wait until the market already dropped 5-600 points? Common sense would indicate a bounce back anyway...

So yes, I could understand this Journal if there was some kind of IMPROVEMENT, but this year it is just bad, bad trading and humiliation.
You know I am trying to help you, but you won't listen. My prediction and advice were perfect and had you followed them, you would be up 3-400 points instead of down -150...
But then again, it is not my money....
 
your points are understood, although not correct.

this is speculation,not active daytrading. position sizing is the key here, not exact entries and winning everytime.

however, the wins, when they come are substantial. the year is not over.

surf
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top