The Surf Report

Status
Not open for further replies.
Quote from Tracy McGreedy:

You could post a snapshot of ur broker executions to prove the doubters. Doesn't seem like to much to ask given fact that the only reason you keep a journal is to seek public notoriety.

Even the most reputable Hedge funds who claim x% returns, provide audited #'s.
More...



im a private person and a retail trader at this time--don't need or wish to raise trading capital. i enjoy writing, hence the journal.

there is no need for me to prove anything as i make no claims to prove.

however, plogic and others make claims both here and on his site regarding his highly effective system. however, when challenged, he answers as he did today--take it as you will.

regards,

surf
 
Quote from ProfLogic:

I trade with two other people everyday in my office. I trade for a living. It doesn't matter what I tell you and it doesn't matter what you believe. Your opinion is valuable to you and that is all that counts.

I'm not trying to impress you or persuade you or anyone else to do anything. I have opinions and I trade based on them. If someone wants to look at what I do an can find some value in it, great but they will prove to themselves it works I don't persuade them it works.

I would show you my account statement if I needed to prove something to you . . . but I don't. I would waste my time posting trades on a tracking site if I needed to prove something . . . but I don't. If I am put into a position where I am asked to prove what I do then I am damn sure going to make the best out of it. I'm not going to do it for free. Hell, I spend about 4 hours a day in front of the screens trading to make money and I damn sure don't do it for free.

I don't need bragging rights. I don't need to brag. Beating Smurf wouldn't be much of a feat. Considering all the torment he has dished out over the years I would think he could put up something of value but alas that isn't the case. Bragging rights, I guess that is what children can afford and think is important today.
More...

Most gurus tell others how PERFECT and OBJECTIVE their methodologies are.

But when challenged to prove their profitablity using objective means... they don't have the balls.

Trading statement ? Collective2 ?... its not going to happened..just excuses excuses and more excuses and a lot more excuses...

On Top of this, some "gurus" told people they would post their statements, but they either post a piece of joke, or quietly eat their own words and hope that people forget what they said they would do. Unfortunately people do remember :)
 
I don't see your posts annaland, so Surf must've had them tossed, but I gotta tell ya, you are just tooo too funny! :p

You got me good, girl.
***
Well, I got the party started, but none of the Big Dogs seem to wanna step up to the plate with me, so, cool.

I gotta give Surf props for being willing to rise to the challenge though.

Good trading,

Jimmy Jam
 
How ridiculous this turned out to be! lol.

Alot of talk and then when it comes down to it, and it looks like it might actually happen , they all find their excuses! priceless.

Surf. Just post a broker shot or something man. It will cement your victory in this cringe-worthy little spat. At least you were willing to do the 'trade-off competition'. Otherwise its a 3 way defeat!
 
Quote from candles:

How ridiculous this turned out to be! lol.

Alot of talk and then when it comes down to it, and it looks like it might actually happen , they all find their excuses! priceless.

Surf. Just post a broker shot or something man. It will cement your victory in this cringe-worthy little spat. At least you were willing to do the 'trade-off competition'. Otherwise its a 3 way defeat!
More...
LOL assclown.

Surf isn't going to post a broker's statement, because he doesn't have one (do they give statements for SIM trading? :confused: ) ...

As far as the competition, I said from the beginning that I was ready and willing to do it, but it takes two to tangle, otherwise there's no competitive spirit.

I seriously hope you don't trade with the same lack of understanding that you've displayed here, otherwise you never really know whether you should be Long or Short.

JJ
 
Here's a recent example of our resident genius at work ...

Quote from candles:

out of short for 3.5 point loss.
More...

LOL, big surprise there!

Jimmy Jam :p

P.S. "I seriously hope you don't trade with the same lack of understanding that you've displayed here, otherwise you never really know whether you should be Long or Short.", it turns out that my original post was prescient. :)
 
Quote from JimmyJam:



Surf isn't going to post a broker's statement, because he doesn't have one (do they give statements for SIM trading? :confused: ) ...



JJ
More...



wrong, callingalljimmyjams.

what your missing is as soon as a statement is posted, the same crowd will cry photo shop, fake, sim account, or whatever.

it's really meaningless.



surf
 
Quote from marketsurfer:

wrong, callingalljimmyjams.

what your missing is as soon as a statement is posted, the same crowd will cry photo shop, fake, sim account, or whatever.

it's really meaningless.



surf
More...
Shrug, post your years performance (so Pekelo can audit it) :p , and we'll see.

Otherwise, it just is what it is ... some guy posting weird trades on an internet forum, claiming to be this, that and the other, but never even showing his cumulative quarterly/yearly performance or taking accountability in any way shape or form (going in, full size now), PU-LEASE. :p

A 7th grade student (or chimp) could definitely do better.

The ony thing around here that's meaningless is this journal.

JJ
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top