Quote from jbtrader23:
It's funny, if it portrayed any other ethnicity, people would be jumping up and down about it.
I don't know that there really much of an issue with which to object. At least not in the context mentioned. I have not watched the HBO prison show...Oz? But from the clips I have seen promoting it, it seems that the prison population is portrayed as mostly black. Is this discriminatory? Or is this a reflection of what is real? In the same vein of thinking, is organized crime, to a great degree comprised of Italian-Americans?
Around the time that "The Godfather" movies were popular, an Italian version of the Anti Defamation League was created (I forget the exact name that they used, but close to the ADL). Ironically it was founded and funded by well known "mafioso". Joe Colombo, if memory serves. Anyway, I am not sure if the organization still exists, but certainly their reason to be was (is?) to make the public aware that the vast majority of Italian-Americans are law abiding citizens. And that the "mafia" stereotype is objectionable to these people.
We all know that Rudi Guilliani was a first rate crime fighter. Targeted Italian run "mafia" figures. John Gotti is off the streets. The "mafia" is in decline. There are now more serious threats to society from other criminal elements.
Black gangsters have been depicted in many books, movies, tv shows, etc. As have Jewish gangsters. "Bugsy Siegel" had his life portrayed in a major hollywood movie. The Meyer Lansky character, "Mo Green", and many others were portrayed in "The Godfather" movies. The movie "Casino".....Robert DeNiro, the quintessential Italian gangster played the role of the real "Lefty" Rosenthal. A true life jewish Vegas bad guy (had a bar here in South Florida until a year or so ago). The examples are endless. The Russian Mafia is now becoming more omnipresent. And therefore more often portrayed in the entertainment industry (including in "The Sopranos"). There are gangsters and gangster stories that can be pointed to from virtually any ethnic group. It is really just entertainment. And if the characters on the Sopranos are offensive to some people, and they consider the material "racist", well certainly they are entitled to their objections. But the truth of the matter is that whether the stereotyping is fair or not is irrelevant. It is truly a matter of free speech and expression. And giving the public what they want.
Anyone who actually watches the show knows that the bad guys are NOT portrayed as being representative of Italians in general. The cast is largely comprised of Italian-American actors and actresses. They seem to have no problem with the issue. The therapist, Dr. Malfi, the "hero" and moral counter-balance in the show is an Italian character.
I don't see that clear thinking people can seriously be convinced by watching this show that Italian-Americans are as a group likely to be gangsters because of their heritage. If anyone is that isolated from reality, it is unlikely they have access to cable television. What is really objectionable here? Is there organized crime comprised of Italian-Americans? Yes. Is it fair to use this element of real life as a basis for entertainment? Obviously this is a personal issue. But it has been part of our society (both the real "mafia" and the fictionalized version). Is it entertaining? Clearly it is and has been. Is it profitable to create this entertainment? Absolutely. The Godfather....written by Mario Puzo ...an Italian American. Directed by Francis Ford Copula. An Italian-American.
Is the Sopranos creating a bad image for Italian-Americans? The real question is, is there INTENT TO DO THIS? Clearly not, and that is why people are not "jumping up and down" protesting the material. It's just entertainment.
I would be interested to know if any Italian-American members of ET are offended by this show. It would surprise me if there were. This show is not causing mass feelings of
anything as far as I can see. Other than people wanting to tune in to a well written, well acted and very entertaining hour of tv. So many people, myself included, who generally do not watch tv seem compelled to make time for "The Sopranos". They must be doing something right.
Peace,

rs7