You are one of the posters I respect so I hate to disagree with you.
Why is it stealing if you willingly publishes the results/methods and I use them to generate a trading recipe? As an example, you mentioned more than once that you often danced options around the underlying. It is an extremely valuable advise for those who understood what that meant. Did I steal from you when I implemented that approach?
Anyway, IMHO it is easy to reverse engineer your trading principles/approaches but very difficult to reverse engineer your discretionary recipe because we don't have your brain.
Best regards,
I think there is a difference by saying I dance options around my positions and someone giving exact times or pictures of what they do, let's face, very small amounts of what I trade was developed strictly by my ideas and 95% came from books, forums, mentors and number of other public displays. Where the work comes in is proving to myself I can not have losses exceed certain percentages, like scalping, my losses stay under 3% base on weekly stats, do I care what others think of me, not at all, I have nothing to prove to anyone, except myself. My very long term commodity system this year being correct is at zero percent so far being for profitable new long term trades, but have many open positions as they not been stopped out yet and a few made it to first and only targets but runners, 90%, far away from those areas. All at breakeven stops plus fees.
Most know I trade extremes, counter-trend at time of entry in almost all areas of trading, 6% of signals are breakouts of anything I do, most people don't have the talent or knowledge or extreme work I have done for so long, most are playing golf and become a limo driver for their younger wives and have retired from trading.
We all grow up differently, some naïve trader just breaming with happiness wants to share his chart, most unaware there are dangerous sharks in these waters, like me, but I take it apart for challenge but don't trade it as I know he was sharing not to share the signals, otherwise he would have gone into fine detail of how he was getting in.
From the beginning, I started this as a challenge, it was a hobby, dangerous hobby, more like a dangerous sport, danced on the edge way too often and got hurt way too much, building blocks of sorts, you have to put in your time, great deal of time, but am horrible dealing with people, can't stand 99% of people and even the 1%, they gets on my nerves as well after so much time. I don't understand or comprehend most emotions except pain, sparse moments of happiness but it is a world I understand, so sport of trading I play is challenge for me, never been about the money-just way to keep score, I think most people who played game this would do much better. I have always made income by physical work, owning real estate and that is work and starting businesses, all involved people unfortunately. You want to get ahead "Work hard and smart", find talented people for managers and cut them some of the net and own piece of the pie, people will work their asses off for you and their families. Quality of Life for those who put in great effort.
@ironchef, glad you put in the hard work and effort to design new system regarding options, did I give or show you how I trade this way? NO, like impossible to re-engineer signals. Don't think one needs big brain to re-engineer, just needs great deal of time of working variety of ways to trade.