Most of the comments there would apply to any sort of trader, e.g.:
<i>
- There is no good reason these high volume, high speed traders should be allowed to continue to operate the way they do. They manipulate and distort the markets, taking profits away from regular investors while adding nothing of value. This is just another way to rig the game for the benefit of the few. Time to end it. Put a limit on the number of trades per day, and slow down the speed at which trades can be entered.</i>
<i>- No matter what they âwantâ to be called, they are part and parcel of what a sick place America has become. They buy influence, and seek to buy even more. They contribute nothing to society of real value. They make a mockery of an honest dayâs work, where men actually EARN what they get paid. And they fit right in with what is fast becoming one of the most easy-to-buy-off and hypocritical governments in the world.</i>
<i>- âAs a group, they earned $12.9 billion in profit in the last two yearsâ. I translate that as: â They skimmed of $12.9 billion of the possible gains of proper investors who invest in industry and commerce to allow them to create value for the world.</i>
When I recently made $1700 in a futures spread trade no doubt those same people would say that I was skimming money from investors without providing any value, that I didn't really EARN the money, that I was manipulating the markets, etc. Certainly the complaints would be even louder about the people here who trade in much larger size than I do (and no doubt, more successfully). So all this whining about high frequency trades from supposed "elite traders" sounds terribly hypocritical. You're just jealous that you didn't think of the HFT thing first.