Gone Baby Gone
***SPOILERS***
Based on the novel by Dennis Lehane, GBG is one of the best film adaptations of recent years. Much more than just your standard detective thriller, it's gritty, realistic, and uncompromising, tackling serious social issues w/o being preachy or offering pat solutions. A little girl goes missing, but instead of a straightforward mystery that is resolved when the girl is found, the good guys experience a profound moral dilemma as to whether or not the child should be returned to her home, since her mother is a junkie who abuses her through neglect, while the kidnappers are actually better parents and provide a loving environment for the child that she has never known. The two private detectives, Patrick and Angie, played by Casey Affleck and Michelle Monaghan, are also lovers who live together, and at the climax they become at odds over whether or not the child should be returned to her mother. This scene is done simply, w/o histrionics, as they wrestle with each other over what is the right thing to do. That their differing views will also affect their relationship adds yet another, personal layer, to their quandary. Observing the little girl in her new home, Angie's argument is simple: "She's happy." Patrick, however, is appalled, that she's asking him to condone and cover-up a kidnapping, to be complicit in something he considers a horrible crime. His decision and the ultimate resolution is disturbing, one that leaves the question open as to whether or not Patrick really makes the right moral choice.
The plot is full of genuine surprises throughout, it's a fine mystery w/lots of twists, and one is never quite sure just who are the bad guys and who are the good guys. The character's motivations are complex - sometimes selfish, sometimes selfless, sometimes a bit of both. And always, moral ambiguity; when Patrick murders a child murderer in a moment of extreme anguish, he later expresses regret and guilt, while the cop hearing his confession assures him he did the right thing.
Affleck is superb, he puts a spin on the traditional P.I., about as far from the standard tough-puy persona as can be imagined. Confused, scared a lot of the time, in over his head, he plays the character as both weak in some respects and brave and uncompromising in others, when it really counts. Monaghan, in a quiet role, mostly in the background, has the perfect look for her character - tough, pretty but not glamorous, she ultimately shows herself as resolute in her beliefs as her lover. Amy Ryan, as the unlikable mother, is quite brilliant and courageous in a performance that elicits both disdain and pity for her character.
Ben Affleck's direction is straightforward, no flourishes, in modern film-noir style. He lets the wonderful script and fine acting carry the day, his direction never gets in the way, he just tells a good story. A fine debut.
Harold