Quote from Cache Landing:
I actually like a majority of the libertarian views, and I'm interested enough that I'm one of the few people I know that watches the 3rd party debates. But I will have to agree with some of the points on this thread.
Libertarians need to be more specific in the actions they condone. Making some vague statement about people having the freedom to make choices in their own self-interest isn't going to cut it. I think they have a great policy regarding tax and business. They need to have an opinion about the moral issues that face the country now. I'm not suggesting that they need to become an active voice in the various movements. But when it comes time to run for office, they must come to a party consensus.
During the last Pres. election I was watching the 3rd party debates. When discussing national debt, war, fiscal/monetary policy, etc I liked everything the libertarian had to say. Then we got to gay rights, abortion, etc. and the libertarian sounded like a broken record that was completely ignorant to current events/issues.
"Our stance is that people should have the liberty to control their own actions."
This makes it sound like they want to have no government regulation on many personal actions that we as a society consider harmful to the wellbeing of the majority population. I wanted to yell at the screen, "Come on man, form an opinion and make a statement so you don't look like an ignorant fool"! I imagine they will have an increasingly tough time fielding questions regarding legal/illegal immigration during the next presidential debate.
That said, if they as a party could form more of a cohesive unit, I do think they have the best shot (although still not a very good one) at breaking up the stupid two-party system that we have currently.
I sort of feel like there is a fair amount of public interest in Libertarian views too. I think it's also going to be interesting to see, if in these next elections, they can come up with persuasive and comprehensive answers to the types of personal liberty questions you brought up, and also if someone can convince a group of voters that voting for a member of the libertarian ticket won't just be throwing their vote away. I think I probably heard this complaint from 4/5 people who mentioned that they thought the libertarians had a persuasive platform. "I'd just be wasting my vote."