Quote from chad_17:
You lost me there buddy .. I know vega is the volatility sensitivity, i know IV shoots up as options prices go up - but I can't understand the claim you make here.. I'm still a beginner ..
As for your statement on adjusting positions, how and when would you adjust, say, a vertical bull call spread, that has a week till expiration and the underlying is trading near the lower strike ..?
Chad,
Well, you are asking pretty good questions for "still a beginner."
I'll try to explain in a different way here. The probability is not sufficient information to tell you what the expected return (the average return over a large number of trades) is. It is necessary to also take into account the amounts of all possible wins and losses.
Suppose you have a so-called 80% iron condor that you are going to hold to expiration. Suppose it has 10 points between the longs and the shorts (I'm just making up some numbers here) and you get 2 points for it. You may tell me that you have an 80% probability of making 2 points if you hold it to expiration, and I agree. However, if holding to expiration, you also have about a 20% probability of losing 8 points.
To get the expected (average) return over a large number of trades, which is what you really need to know, multiply all the probabilities by their respective payoffs and add them up:
prob of win*payoff of win + prob of loss*payoff of loss
(0.8 prob of win)*(2 point payoff) + (0.2 prob of loss)*(-8 point payoff) = 1.6 - 1.6 = 0
So far I have ignored the fact that there is a small area between the short and the long where your return at expiration lies between +2 and -8. But, if you add up the products of all the payoffs and probabilities along that portion of the graph, they will also sum to zero.
I'm just saying that this is true for all these trades, *if* held to expiration, which is only another way of saying that options tend to be reasonably fairly priced. Therefore it behooves you to do something besides blindly hold to expiration, whether that is make an educated guess about volatility and/or skew in the first place, spread positions across different strikes, adjust at opportune times, use insurance, exit if you have a decent profit and there is little to be gained by staying in, exit if something crazy is brewing with the fundamentals, etc.
I don't trade very many verticals, so unfortunately I don't have a suggested adjustment for you. I am sure others can chime in who know more about how to do that.... and good luck.
Any time you adjust, you are giving something else up, and you need to see what that something is. Someone here turned me on to Paul Forchione's books. You may find them helpful for adjustments.