Quote from thriftybob:
You asked for detailed proof, and now are angry I provided it?
Her VERY FIRST CHECK was about equal to the TOTAL AMOUNT she put in.
How many more people collected similar sums in excess of their payments? What was the withholding percentage and cap back then? If the money had been SAVED and earned interest, they wouldn't big need increases now to cover the shortfalls.
People are living longer, I'll grant that is true, but to argue the system is solvent and then say it needs a 14% increase in tax rate is sort of silly.
And lastly, and most importantly, WHO is going to repay all those IOU's?
I am totally exasperated. Are you just being this dense to annoy me or are you actually retarded. If you are retarded than I apologize for my lack of patience, but how can I possibly spell it out any more clearly than I already have? It is a 16% increase in the tax that is needed based on the 2009 report. In 2009, the rate was 12.4% but needs to be 14.4%. Now pay attention! Because (14.4 - 12.4)/ 12.4 = .16 , that is a 16% increase in the tax, AND because 14.4 - 12.4 = 2, that is 2 cents more tax per every dollar earned, AND because the tax is split equally between employer and employee that is a whopping 1 cent more for each dollar earned that the employer will have to pay and a whopping 1 cent more per dollar earned that the employee will need to pay. Now then, those are the figures for 2009 and 2010. The employee contribution was actually reduced a little in 2011.
Now it gets worse, much much worse for self employed people. They will have to pay the entire two cents more per dollar of additional tax all by themselves. Oh, woe is me!!!
It is the nature of shared risk, defined benefit plans that some will receive more than their total contributions plus interest, and others will receive less than their total contributions plus interest, depending on how long they live. GET IT! The risk of receiving less in benefits than your total contribution is the trade off for lower monthly contributions throughout your working years and a pension that you can not outlive, no matter how long you live.
Now, is it finally clear to you --no, I suppose not -- that every thing you thought you knew about Social Security is dead wrong and there is a concerted effort by Wall Street and the Republicans in congress to mis-characterize the system, lie about it, and weaken it however they can. Won't it be nice when your grandmother is on the street eating cat food!
