SouthAmerica...excellent commentary
The broad based arguments that you make to me are theoretically correct...
However these countries ie CAFTA...etc...have no meaningful comparative advantages...and ie although 25000 pesos a month is poor in the US..it is very respectable as a middle class income...the family can live a dignified life...However when agreements arrive that allow for big company intervention...countless numbers of middle class small businesses will be eliminated...the retired older class who had the money to retire..no longer have the money to retire...the list goes on and on....
Extremely low interest rates are very destructive....Extremely high interest rates are destructive....
If you look at the full spectrum...troubled countries have interest rates in the 12 to 25% range....all the way to supposed stable countries which are less than 5%...
In the US....If retirees use 5% as an interest indicator...it takes $1,000,000 in cash to get a pretax rate of $50,000 per year...now what % of the US population has this...
This is indeed not healthy...and nor are extremely high levels...but even with high levels..the middle class has a chance if they save money and gather the interest that is made available to them...
Savers in Turkey...Indonesia...Brazil...Argentena...Honduras...Dominican Republic fared better than citizens in the US when you combined the interest paid plus capital in the currency... and their problems are still around...
ie..The US has offered 1x1.02x1.01x1.01x1.02/1 vs 17x1.17x1.2x1.3x1.15/29....ie a recent example...
In the US...you just spend whatever money you have with no chance of making it...along with the lowest paying economies...
Obviously...there are always going to be efficiency issues ...but when efficiency knocks out a generation or two of hard working..intelligent middle class people,,this is not the right solution...these people matter too...this is 20 to 50 years of time...
The incentive to save is paramount to any healthy economy...In the US people save what they save because of tax reasons...
Each healthy economy needs big cowboy populations that think they can win....when big brother and big business comes to town...this is just not possible...
I really do like your commentary...and as you can tell...I am very interested in this line of thinking...
Finished trading for the day...enjoy batting around ideas...
The broad based arguments that you make to me are theoretically correct...
However these countries ie CAFTA...etc...have no meaningful comparative advantages...and ie although 25000 pesos a month is poor in the US..it is very respectable as a middle class income...the family can live a dignified life...However when agreements arrive that allow for big company intervention...countless numbers of middle class small businesses will be eliminated...the retired older class who had the money to retire..no longer have the money to retire...the list goes on and on....
Extremely low interest rates are very destructive....Extremely high interest rates are destructive....
If you look at the full spectrum...troubled countries have interest rates in the 12 to 25% range....all the way to supposed stable countries which are less than 5%...
In the US....If retirees use 5% as an interest indicator...it takes $1,000,000 in cash to get a pretax rate of $50,000 per year...now what % of the US population has this...
This is indeed not healthy...and nor are extremely high levels...but even with high levels..the middle class has a chance if they save money and gather the interest that is made available to them...
Savers in Turkey...Indonesia...Brazil...Argentena...Honduras...Dominican Republic fared better than citizens in the US when you combined the interest paid plus capital in the currency... and their problems are still around...
ie..The US has offered 1x1.02x1.01x1.01x1.02/1 vs 17x1.17x1.2x1.3x1.15/29....ie a recent example...
In the US...you just spend whatever money you have with no chance of making it...along with the lowest paying economies...
Obviously...there are always going to be efficiency issues ...but when efficiency knocks out a generation or two of hard working..intelligent middle class people,,this is not the right solution...these people matter too...this is 20 to 50 years of time...
The incentive to save is paramount to any healthy economy...In the US people save what they save because of tax reasons...
Each healthy economy needs big cowboy populations that think they can win....when big brother and big business comes to town...this is just not possible...
I really do like your commentary...and as you can tell...I am very interested in this line of thinking...
Finished trading for the day...enjoy batting around ideas...