Quote from gerry875:
if you talk about contraction and expansion - that's nothing new - it's the no. 1 principle of all markets and all timeframes.
but that is not the topic here - it's about books that obviously don't exist.
Actually, you are the thread starter and you did
ask me to name one specific example where I learned something from Jack Hershey.
Therefore, it is the topic because you made it the topic by asking me that question.
The issue isn't about whether the info is discussed a million times or not by others nor how long its been discussed.
The issue is that I am at a current phase in my trading where his comments about
volatility compression caused me to do further research into what others had to say.
In other words, someone else could have said the exact same thing at the exact same time I was searching for something to help with a particular aspect of Volatility Analysis...
They didn't and Jack did.
In addition, others have done their research and posted links in the past to the info that you seek or continue to argue about...
Some books do exist, some manuals do exist and some articles do exist.
The real question...are there 30 books?
I've NEVER seen anywhere where he said he written 30 technical analysis books nor mention any other book being on a bestsellers list.
If he said that...please find the quote and post it.
However, I have a strong feeling you could care less by how many books he has written even if someone decides to post the link for you to
one book.
The real issue is reflected in your most recent comments.
You think he's a smartass, extraordianary claims and interrupts other threads.
Also, correct if I'm wrong, didn't he get banned for advertising or promotion and for saying something bad to a moderator?
Thus, he didn't get banned for thread interruptions nor for not being able to verified his own trading ability.
Therefore, like others that got banned and returned...the reason why they have not been banned again was because they have not broken the rules again that pssst off Baron.
Simply, if Jack starts advertising again...I'm sure Baron wouldn't hesitate to warn him or ban him again if he gets a complaint about such.
I know this sounds off topic but you (not me) are now changing the direction of this thread but at least its going in the direction of its
true purpose.
Moderators...
Chit Chat forum dungeon please because this thread should have never been posted in the Educational Resources section.
Mark
