@destriero, I am not smart enough to understand what you wrote.
This I understand:
If
@Sweet Bobby sells a put and then immediately executes a "hedge" using his ratio spread, it is just some combination spreads and I can't see how it could generate a guaranteed profit. It is similar to buying a stock, immediately executes a zero cost collar and expects to generate a profit.
His put selling is selective, the puts were sold only under certain conditions (according to
@Sweet Bobby). The ratio spreads were also selective, they were executed only under certain conditions. There is no profit if both are done blindly and together. Until we know the selectivity, we really cannot say if his method has any merits.
This is not unlike your situation:
You make a living trading flies, but I lost my shirt trading flies. I can't say you fake it because I can't duplicate. But I make a living buying and selling stand alone calls and puts. You can't say I fake it because generally buying and selling calls/puts won't net a profit.
So
@Sweet Bobby makes a good living selling puts and catching an occasional black swan. He disclosed his approach, it is testable. Whether it works or not I appreciate him sharing.
Best to you.