Quote from Maverick74:
BTW, I'm thinking of trying something new here. In an effort to compartmentalize ACD, I'm thinking of starting separate ACD threads under various product categories. I would start with ACD FX under the FX forum. That thread would focus only on FX and ACD. Then maybe a thread in the energy forum, metals, stocks, etc. This way one can follow just the products they are interested in following and this thread will stay more for general ACD questions. What do you guys think?
Quote from Maverick74:
BTW, I'm thinking of trying something new here. In an effort to compartmentalize ACD, I'm thinking of starting separate ACD threads under various product categories. I would start with ACD FX under the FX forum. That thread would focus only on FX and ACD. Then maybe a thread in the energy forum, metals, stocks, etc. This way one can follow just the products they are interested in following and this thread will stay more for general ACD questions. What do you guys think?

Quote from Maverick74:
BTW, I'm thinking of trying something new here. In an effort to compartmentalize ACD, I'm thinking of starting separate ACD threads under various product categories. I would start with ACD FX under the FX forum. That thread would focus only on FX and ACD. Then maybe a thread in the energy forum, metals, stocks, etc. This way one can follow just the products they are interested in following and this thread will stay more for general ACD questions. What do you guys think?

Quote from Maverick74:
BTW, I'm thinking of trying something new here. In an effort to compartmentalize ACD, I'm thinking of starting separate ACD threads under various product categories. I would start with ACD FX under the FX forum. That thread would focus only on FX and ACD. Then maybe a thread in the energy forum, metals, stocks, etc. This way one can follow just the products they are interested in following and this thread will stay more for general ACD questions. What do you guys think?
Quote from OneFive:
I know I don't contribute much here but I find the thread very valuable and appreciate the lack of extraneous noise. With respect to separate threads, I do think you run the risk of fragmentation. While the thread has been active lately, there have been some pretty quiet stretches. I'm not sure how product threads would fare once they went quiet. I guess the main question I would ask is: "Will there be enough product specific discussion to warrant a separate thread?" In my mind, many of the product specific examples that are given here still play back into the broader context of ACD as a methodology. The opportunity to see how others apply it to various products that I may not trade is useful.