Quote from Maverick74:
OK, I'll throw out a bone here. For stocks, the best way to look for good confirmed A ups and A downs is to look for narrow open ranges. You want to program this into a ratio. Take the OR into say a 30 day ATR. Then run the scans during the day to find the tightest ratios, for example all stocks under 20%. From this list, you look for confirmed A ups and A downs. Combine that with stocks with narrow pivots or narrowing pivots, and you will find your breakouts.
To further add to this, you can do the same process with stocks using a 30 min OR and look for late morning breakouts which actually tend to have more follow through then the early morning breakouts or breakdowns.
The problem with the failed A trades is noise. There just are too many of them and you will never find the best ones nor will you have any ability to filter for the nice ones. They will all be random. The breakout trades can be isolated. For example, you can get very very narrow by lowering the OR/ATR ratio to 15% or 12% to really fine tune the breakouts. You can't do this with fade trades. Simply looking for stocks with wide OR is meaningless because some will provide great fades and some will not. That's like saying the market might go up today or might go down. This will become very frustrating over time the sheer randomness of it.
Anyway, just a thought...