Quote from Maverick74:
Not at all. Look, I think it would help here to differentiate between stocks and futures. Futures have lots of intra-day movements and follow through. Stocks are tougher since they don't trade 24 hours like most futures do, stocks gap and move hard on the open then in many cases spend all day in a trading range.
The entire Logical Trader book was dedicated to day trading, not longer term trading. I think MFbreakout has done a great job on this thread showing how he uses it to trade CL which has lots of follow through. And I've said this time and time again, you need to know the product you are trading. GE stock does not trade the same way as CL. And CL does not trade the same as ZB. You have to treat these products differently.
With stocks, you need to be very careful with stock selection. You can't just trade AAPL every day. You have to watch the news flow, earnings, volume, other things. Stocks are not easy to trade. I've said this for years on this forum. Part of that is because there are so many of them and it takes one a lot of experience to select the right stocks to daytrade.
There is plenty of follow through in stocks, but you have to be in the right ones. I know I'm stating the obvious when I say that, but it really is as simple as that.
As far as trading failed A ups and A downs, again, I've said this before it comes down to your style. Is that the kind of trader you are? Because if it's not, I assure you ACD will not make you profitable trading that way. You have to trade your personalty. If you like to follow trends, you will find fading moves very hard. If you like to fade, you will find staying in a trend very hard.
Once again, ACD is a methodology, not a system. So whatever you are doing now without ACD, just lay ACD on top of that. If you trade CL before, then trade it now. If you trade breakouts now, then lay ACD on top of that to trade breakouts better. Don't fight what comes natural to you because you "think" ACD will work better.