What makes Bama evil?Roger that
What makes Bama evil?Roger that
What I talk about in this journal applies to any instrument. It is PA. One does have to make adjustments as some instruments are more volatile than others but PA is price action.
The market cycle should always be a context one wants to identify before attempting to trade. It determines the tools one will use.I watched enough Brooks this weekend to be dangerous to myself. Trading SIM and trading the M2K micro contract of the RTY.
Also watching the ES.
So far, so good. I have a lot to watch still, but the Market Cycle stuff that you posted about recently is gold knowledge, in my opinion.
I'm a non-daytrader, so take it for what its worth.
Good Morning Volpri,1) Yes I have always loathed losing. It eats on me. Of course, trading is about making money but it also is about liking what you do or burn out will soon appear. I had to devise a way I could scalp quickly, maintain a high win rate so I could be “happy” while trading. I simply could not stand losing 9 trades in a row and on my 10th trade make 5 times what I lost on the previous 9. Even though money wise I would be just fine, psychologically I would be a miserable human being. Trading has to be fun. If I can get my lazy carcass out of bed by the open I can’t wait to gulp down a cup of coffee and start trading. Even if yesterday was a losing day. “Yesterday is gone, Tomorrow is a mystery, today I can make a difference”
2) not really but I have always scalped probably 97% of the time. I scalped stocks back in the day before they came out with that damn decimal system. I loved watching several stocks on the NYSE and the AMEX and when the specialist would widen the spread I would jump in the spread and get me 1/8, a 1/4, or a 1/2 point. That was the specialist bread and butter. That belonged to him and they could get pissed when a retail trader is dipping his hand in their cookie jar. Decimals ruined that.
3) a high win rate for me personally is necessary because I am a scalper of 1 to 8 points. IMO a scalper, to make it, has to have a high win rate. A high win rate means I accept quick profits and avoid those whipsaws. I do not like seeing a profit then “puff” it disappears before I can bat an eyelash 5 times. “A bird in the hand is worth 5 in the bush”. I am reminded of the little boy who told the grown man that he had a real fast bird and that he would bet the man $5.00 that when he open his hand that the man could not grab the bird before it flew away. They each put up $5.00. The boy: “you ready?” The man “yes open that hand!” The boy opens his hand and the man snatches at whatever is in the boys closed hand. All he grabs is some bird crap. The little boy tells him “I told you that was a fast bird.” The man say says “where did it go?” The boy says as he is picking up the mans $5.00; “I don’t know where it went all I know is that bird done sh$t and gone.”
A high win rate when when scalping means that because I am scalping I get MORE trading opportunities and a likely chance to compound. For instance say price is dancing around back and forth 4 points. I can go in and grab 2 points and likely get right back in maybe even 3 more times grabbing another point or two each time instead of waiting 30 minutes for some mystery move that will render me 6 points. I can make 1 or 2 points over and over during that 30 minute wait. Because I am scalping for quick profits the odds favor me getting them thus they favor a high win rate. Look not everybody wants to trade that way but I love it. It suits me. I am in the middle of the action swinging the machete.
I am reminded of the class in elementary school and the teacher had the students tell a story then share the moral of the story with the class. Lydia “would you start off” says the teacher? “Lydia says I live on a farm and we raise chickens and sell the eggs. One day we gathered a large basket of eggs and went to town in grandpa’s old pickup to sell the eggs. Grandpa can’t see too good and hit pothole in the road. Half of the eggs broke.” “That is too bad Lydia I am sorry to hear that say the teacher but can you tell us the moral of the story?” Yes, responds Lydia “the moral is never put all your eggs in one basket!”
Very good Lydia now Johnny you share a story and it’s moral. “Ok” says Johnny and proceeds to tell the story. “Aunt Betsy joined the military and went over to the war zone as a paratrooper. They flew over the jump zone in the middle of the enemy territory. As they are jumping out she is the last one to jump. As she is making her way to the door she see a full bottle of whiskey. “Why not” she says? She grabs the bottle and a machete laying on the floor and jumps out. As she is going down 100 enemy troops are firing at her. She thinks “ they might hit this bottle of whiskey and break it so I better drink it down.” She gets finished then cast the bottle aside and takes her weapon and begins firing hard and fast at the enemy. By the time she hits the ground she has killed 50 of them. But her gun is out of ammo. She grabs the machete and kills another 40. Then the machete breaks into two pieces. She throws it down and kills the other 10 with her bare hands. The teacher say “Johnny that is a horrible horrible story.” Can you tell the class the moral of that story, if it even has one? Johnny replies: “the moral of the story is don’t mess with Aunt Betsey when she has been drinking!”
4) Yes, I do but that is contrary to what all the gurus say. Why? It is much easier to assess what price is likely in the next 5 or 10 minutes that what it is likely to do in the next 4 hours or 4 days. Kind of like weather forecasting. The present conditions (context) makes it easier for the weatherman to postulate a likely weather scenario for the next 2 or 3 days than say speculate on it for a month from now or a year from now. In scalping one is closer to the actual present context of things and it is more likely that one can place a SAFER bet on where price will likely be in the next few minutes. Second, one's money is only at risk when one is in the market. Once out, the risk is over. Third, scalping lends itself, by nature, to compounding profits. By nature because the market is like a big auction. Price probing back forth. Price is gonna go where the most transactions take place. Otherwise, brokers would get really really mad with the exchanges! ROFLMAO. So, for instance buy 1 contract of ES at 4400. Sell with 2 points profit. You got a locked in profit! Price probes back down 3 points go long again a point cheaper than your previous entry. Price goes back up to your previous exit. You make 3 more points. In essence you are compounding because you already locked in a profit and are using it to make another, and a bigger profit at that!
5) That I could not tell without looking at what that trader is doing that is causing him not to be profitable. If I have no access to that info the only thing I could tell him is journal every trade as you make it live on the chart (much like I do) and then shortly after the session within the next few days analyze his entries and exits and try to discover what he is doing wrong and come up with a strategy to correct whatever is causing him to not be profitable.
Insights like that is not written in the book..Notice I am going long on a general sloping trend up and price is near the bottom of the sideways
Hello Volpri,Here is a trade that illustrates what I am talking about in terms of price probing in slow moving markets. This was a trade taken a few moments ago.
We had a little PA TR behavior. This is a 5 min chart. MES.
We had a little TR behavior before 20 bars of sideways movement was reached.
A couple of bars prior to the first bar on the left were also in the PA TR behavior just not shown. So counting the bars we got 5 bars (from that doji with red gap under it) Then two additional bear bars to arrive at my entry bar. So 7 bars TR behavior by my entry bar. I enter long on a position on the second bear bar after the drawn in gap. I am betting that red gap will be filled. The dotted line is from the red gap to the green entry triangle.
Notice I am going long on a general sloping trend up and price is near the bottom of the sideways movement. That just puts a few more odds in my favor. It cannot yet be defined as a TR (takes 20 bars to do that) but it is TR behavior. By that I mean overlapping bars. Bull ...bear...doji (dojis are one bar TR's) ..etc. In other words, small price probing north and south. There is a difference in TR behavior and actual TR. The former can end anytime before TR is reached. The latter, if reached, tends to continue for a while.
So, this trade is in the TR behavior arena, Price is moving slow. Bars are not large. I capitalize on price probes north and south using fill the gap techniques.
The red gap (signified by the vertical red rectangle) is the gap I want to see filled. So, I am long and exit 1/2 position on first red triangle 1 point profit and the other 1/2 of the position at 2 points profit on the second red triangle.
I did get a little adverse movement before the profitable exits but that is not uncommon.
The entry and exits done with limit orders.
Hopefully this illustrates the concepts. You may want to practice on a SIM. It is important to learn to identify the dynamic of the moves to decide is one is going for 1 point profit on the entire position or 1 pt on 1/2 and the other half at 2 pts profit.
View attachment 270255
For example, lets say a trader is risking $100 (2 points) to make $50 (1 point) scalping the ES.