Nonsense!Based on that logic, the market is nearly all noise and nearly always priced incorrectly.

You are not your thoughts and your emotions. Both are fleeting. They appear and disappear as quickly as they came, but you remain. Nor can you control them for any enduring time. They appear upon your consciousness at will like like clouds upon a clear blue sky only to quickly be replaced by subsequent ones. You cannot stop your mind from creating thoughts. Whether true thought or false thoughts but you can mitigate the damage they can do to your trading and other areas of life. You must learn to separate yourself from your thoughts and emotions. They are not you. They appears as clouds and quickly dissipate. Learn to just observe them and not let them encapsulate you and form you into their mold. As traders we need to detach ourselves.
Then smart money is the reason for the movement. It wasn’t random. There was a move initiated by smart money! Price even if it moves 1 tick was because an institution wanted it to move that one tick. It simply is not noise. What is noise are the thoughts and emotions of our minds.No noise or randomness in the markets assumes that all humans are logical.
No noise or randomness in the markets assumes that life lacks noise and randomness.
The conclusion I jump to is some people must believe markets and life is God ordained and there is no such thing in His plan for such things as noise or randomness. Those same people just flat out disbelieve in randomness because "it's all in the plan". Impossible to argue/reason against this type thinking.
I'll never change my opinion, markets have lots of noise and randomness.
The reason they trend as it were (which allows traders to take positions and profit reasonably consistently) is because larger position traders are the smart money who push and co ordinate direction, who know a bargain when presented. Some 'dumb money' are smart enough to recognise smart money and coat-tail which then accentuates trend direction. However dumb money is mostly not smart enough to know when smart money exit, hence price over shoots.
Price falls back to earth due to lack of smart money support.
I don’t recall hearing of her? Is her book worth reading?Geez man, sounds like you have been reading Jane Roberts's material.
I 100% disagree.Price even if it moves 1 tick was because an institution wanted it to move that one tick. It simply is not noise.
And those thought and emotions become the product of the dumb money crowd (and trickster traders) which are the incomprehensible trades.What is noise are the thoughts and emotions of our minds.