Technical analysis
- Thread starter Josh Stefaniak
- Start date
I never removed any of my posts, you pointed out 1 mistake in the tally, which I have omitted, all others were your own errors and attempts to discredit. Magna knows I didn't request any deleting of my posts.
I said you had my evidence of your mistakes removed. You either misread or twist the truth again.
Look I am not interested in playing kindergarten with you. Everyone inclined to check on your funny performance acrobatics can check himself. There is no need to go back and forth between us anymore.
Look I am not interested in playing kindergarten with you. Everyone inclined to check on your funny performance acrobatics can check himself. There is no need to go back and forth between us anymore.
Last edited:
What's the purpose of allowing ANOTHER one of these TA threads to continue after you clearly have seen the personal attacks that prompts you to make these warning like messages.
I think it is just strange considering the info is not education, repetition by the same usual folks and an eye sore.
Simply, is Elitetrader.com forum now that desperate for view counts, post counts that these types of thread needs to remain open because it is clearly starting to look that way ???
In addition, I know you moderators or Baron have the ability to pin at the top any thread you want. Why can't you just select one of these heavily debated TA threads that obviously is full of attacks by the same folks and just leave it at the top instead of just allowing the constant vomiting of the same crap by the same folks ???
Just seem very odd you just continue giving warnings when in the past these types of threads quickly and easily was shoveled like manure down into the Chit Chat thread section of this forum.
Shame on the moderation at this forum if you seriously believe these people will review their messages before posting it while some have clearly been warned several times about participating in these types of threads (threaten with being banned from the forum or thread) and yet they continue ignoring the warnings to continue the same crap !!!
Its time to put the plastic bag on your hand and pick up the crap and drop it in the Chit Chat section.
P.S. Baron or someone changed the ignore feature back to the way it was when it stunk. Now I can see everybody on my ignore list but not their messages and I can see the messages of those quoting someone that's on my ignore list but not the message. Simply, just their user name appears but no message (very strange).
It was nice for a few weeks or month where I could not see at all the person on my ignore list and I could not see the messages by someone that was quoting someone on my ignore list.
Now that the old ignore feature is back...it has resulted in me to spend less time at this forum. I obviously preferred the new ignore feature where these people didn't exist at all...no evidence they are even a member of this forum.
Last edited:
You might be happier in the pay-for-free-butt-slapping Big Mike forum environment, although saying that markets are random in any way that affects day traders might get you labelled a troll.
With regards to Romik, we will just have to disagree. As he points out, if he was going to lie, he wouldn't lie about a trade that was a minor loss. But if your mind is made up that Romik is cheating, then so be it.
With regards to pumping your own ideas, that's fair, you aren't pumping, but you did suggest that your method is so much better, or rather, since you don't believe in TA, you suggest that what you do works and yet what the TA crowd does doesn't work. So now you have opened yourself up to scrutiny by saying that what you do works. Why should we trust you?
I agree, once again, that there isn't a good account here of someone taking PA/TA concepts, showing how they use price to forecast a direction, find an entry, show that entry, and complete this with either a stop out or profit, and do this for a sufficient series of trades to show that they are statistically beyond what could be deemed luck. I can tell you personally that execution is the hardest part of this game, and sadly, this is where I'm seeing the least amount of info here at ET.
So if you want to protect newbies, that's all well and good, but all you really have to go on is that nobody is showing the complete picture. But, and this is my strongest point, you aren't offering anything to advance this discussion any further. We all agree there is not enough proof, or as has always been my complaint, no demonstration of trading in the live environment, but at the very least, the TA crowd gives me something to go on. If I started to say your method is crap, you cannot possibly make money, how would you respond to my claim? In fact, why don't I try...
I dare @volpunter to show me, with enough proof, that he can make money in the markets because if he doesn't, its proof that he is just a troll.
-- if showing proof you can make money in the markets was a requirement...i bet 95%+ of the people here would randomly vanish into thin air.