Technical Analysis = CRAP

logic_man · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from marketsurfer:

That's all well and good---- but still you and the other objective TA true believers have FAILED to offer anything into evidence other than rhetoric, claims and blustery proclamations that your objective TA system has any value.

How about a few before the fact calls, a before the fact journal, anything other than the reposting of charts recording the markets transitions. I have done it for 11 plus years-- where's your evidence?

surf

Alright, man, fair enough with the point of making at least some calls. Right now, I like 1317.25 ES before 1354.75.

For the record, I'm not claiming any BS like 100% accuracy or anything so outrageous, so if the call doesn't work, it doesn't work.

Fireplace · Jul 10, 2011

Nothing to do with you sport, what he said resonated very strongly with my experiences. Not everything is about you ya know.

Quote from marketsurfer:

Getting double teamed here by the logical family.

RCG Trader · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from marketsurfer:

That's all well and good---- but still you and the other objective TA true believers have FAILED to offer anything into evidence other than rhetoric, claims and blustery proclamations that your objective TA system has any value.

How about a few before the fact calls, a before the fact journal, anything other than the reposting of charts recording the markets transitions. I have done it ( in public ) for 11 plus years-- where's your evidence?

surf

And that is one reason why I respect you surf, misguided tho you are. No one is going to give you a working TA system. Except Prof, but he is a different bird.

BTW, congrats, you dumbass

RCG Trader · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from RCG Trader:

And that is one reason why I respect you surf, misguided tho you are. No one is going to give you a working TA system. Except Prof, but he is a different bird.

BTW, congrats, you dumbass

The dumbass was meant in the best possible way Surf.

It's time for a new week, Australia is open, the dollar is firming up. 200+ pips so far, and it's a free trade too

marketsurfer · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from RCG Trader:

The dumbass was meant in the best possible way Surf. It's time for a new week, Australia is open, the dollar is firming up. 200+ pips so far, and it's a free trade too

I know, my brother--no worries. Thanks for the heads up on the USD--- I'm planning on getting back in the game in several weeks!

surf

RCG Trader · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from marketsurfer:

I know, my brother--no worries. Thanks for the heads up on the USD--- I'm planning on getting back in the game in several weeks!

surf

Nothing like making money to the Lido Shuffle (prolly should not post this, someone will definitely use this against me)

If you get sore, you know, Bag Balm will help out a lot. It's for cows, but it works wonders man! A little Heartland tip there. You'll be back at it in six hours and a hot shower

ProfLogic · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from marketsurfer:

I am not famiar with ACD. Is it a knock off of Crabel's opening range breakout?

Google is available for the computer and internet challenged.

ProfLogic · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from marketsurfer:

Folks,

Lets see the proof, TA true believers or no question there isn't any

Surf

July 2011 - FUTURES MAGAZINE COVER - Mark Rosenberg seems like a decent example of of objective "Trend Following" TA and the algorithms he created. Those algorithms have worked for over 40 years. In his fund he has had only 2 losing years out of the last 25.

Definitely not what I do but I think it is one good example of what is possible.

Now shut the hell up and go take care of Anna.

ProfLogic · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from marketsurfer:

How about a few before the fact calls, a before the fact journal, anything other than the reposting of charts recording the markets transitions. I have done it ( in public ) for 11 plus years-- where's your evidence?

surf

Did you forget about my
Euro Call?
Crude Call?

Before the fact
Without pretty charts?

Alzheimer's now too?

ProfLogic · Jul 10, 2011

Quote from marketsurfer:

Getting double teamed here by the logical family.

???

Are you paranoid or what?

I've never met logicman or Fireplace in my life and never spoke to either till I PM'd Fireplace a few weeks ago.

You need help.