Synthesizing Brooks...
I don't have much time right at the moment to read the books written by Al Brooks, but in preparing to do so in the future, I noticed that the first paragraph in the section on Day Trading in his Trading Price Action Reversals publication states that...
If you are not yet consistently profitable, you should not be looking at one- or two-point scalps in the Emini or 10 to 20 cent scalps in stocks as the cornerstone of your trading. In fact, you should avoid scalps until you are an experienced trader, because you need a very high winning percentage to be profitable, and that is difficult for even experienced traders to achieve.
When I traded stocks back in 2008 to 2010, I wasn't necessarily looking for 10 to 20 cent scalps. In general, I think a 20¢ move might have been about the minimum in which I would have been seriously interested. Nonetheless, I'm glad I didn't take this advice when I began trading Forex.
I've been able to scalp the Forex market successfully ever since November of 2015. On the other hand, try as I might, year after year, I never could make money going at it using a longer time frame. It wasn't until I finally figured out how to expand what I was doing as a day trader up to pseudo swing trading that I was able to begin shooting for 10- to 30-pip trades as opposed to 4- to 10-pip trades—and this probably did not happen until relatively recently, perhaps the second half of last year (2018). Learning to day trade profitably, learning to scalp the Forex market, was much, much, much, much easier in my case!
And even still, now that my system is more or less complete, as a retail trader, the idea of straight up swing trading, or worse yet, position trading, at least in the Forex market, would be absolutely crazy from my point of view. Exchange rates skip around WAY too much to be shooting for more than 10 to 30 pips at a time from what I observe. I don't have the capital to weather the large-sized draw downs this would entail, and the substantial losses that might be incurred.
The only exception would be to remain in trades that are running, but this would have to be accomplished by managing positions in the moment, not by setting take-profit targets in advance. So again, for me personally, this would actually encourage me to approach the market from more of a scalping type mindset, and is also the very reason why my percentage of successful trades is so high.
I do realize however that trading foreign currency pairs removes the enormous impediment to scalping stocks profitably that one is going to encounter in the equity market in the form of ridiculously-sized commissions and transaction fees, though.