Surf's Special Situation Journal

[Ol' Yella]

Quote from marketsurfer:

Audits!? From an anonymous Internet snake oiler. LMFAO!

surf

PS
are you banned from trading? Is that why you keep pushing the student or rookie? The SEC didn't like performance claims or WTF?

I love to believe in rags to riches stories, that this guy can take a kid who knows nothing about trading and within a couple of months have him doubling 10k accounts each day. that would be awesome if true...

but no one in their right mind can take it seriously

if he really wanted to prove something he'd have hooked the "students" account into myfxbook or some other 3rd party and blown everyone away already.

I dont believe he intends to submit anything for an audit either

he's bluffing, and trying to stir things up for his own entertainment in my opinion

I think he's just playing around online for fun.

if he does actually mentor ppl then cornix better ask for his money back LOL

in his 3rd party report he made 80-90 pips for the month...

nothing to be ashamed of at all--- very nice accomplishment--- but that is not nearly enough to double a 10k acct each day

80 pips is avg 4 pips a day, 90 is 4.5... that isnt going to double an account! Cornix better get his refund!

 

[marketsurfer]

hey ol yella--- its just more subterfuge, folks like that are very skilled at verbal gymnastics. think about it, his Rookie fails, he blames the Rookie, his Rookie wins, he gets the glory, he CAN NOT LOSE by trying to set things in such a bizarro manner. Other than being banned from the markets ( or elite trader), this is the only other thing that makes sense.

 

[Ol' Yella]

that assumes the rookie actually exists

I doubt it, he's spinning yarns IMO

 

[oraclewizard77]

Why not just use an annual statement? Picking random months is not proof. If he outperformed the S&P index, that is proof enough.

Quote from marketsurfer:

Thanks. I have never been to vans but hear its very good. Did 5 napkin the other day--- that place rocks!

Sure, if he posts just 3 statements--- I'll say he has credibility. I pick the 3 months from the last 12 to prevent cherry picking . Don't hold your breath, he will never do it.

surf

PS-- Cornix evidence made no sense to me since it came out of thin air--- in other words he MAY have just picked a string of 50 solid trades. Whenever he wants to start again, i am all ears. surf

 

[marketsurfer]

Quote from oraclewizard77:

Why not just use an annual statement? Picking random months is not proof. If he outperformed the S&P index, that is proof enough.

Just trying to make it as easy as possible for the stealth vendor. I randomly pick the months, it's not traditional proof, but it's good enough for me.

 

[oraclewizard77]

2006 +27.5% +7.8% (5%) +5.7% (1.2%) +1.4% +10.1%
2007 +4.3% +0.2% +6.8% (3.3%) (9.3%) (1.8%) +6.3% +1.3% +4.1% +1.7% +4.8% (2.8%)
2008 +4.9%

These are the % returns per month of a system I managed for people. This is real money that I made on Forex for myself and them. I don't trade Forex anymore, I trade futures. This is from their website not something I created for this message. I can't link to their website since its not allowed by ET.

I am also still waiting to get approved to trade the Combine and I will let you know when that occurs. I sent them another PM. Hopefully, they are not afraid to let me try since they think I am going to pass it.

 

[cornix]

Quote from Ol' Yella:

Why bother with the auditing....

why not use the 3rd party that corn used....

I remember he posted a record here last year for Surf

link it to the account traded...

cant fake that

at least I dont think anyone could fake it--- the trades go from the traded acct into the 3rd party system

and anyone can go to the site and see the results

and you arent losing profits by simming in a Combine

but why do I guess that will never happen either


it's too easy for someone to fake an audited form, or to back out at the last minute and refuse to submit anything for audit

use a 3rd party and no one can fake it or wriggle out at the last minute--- so results are indisputable

Nope can't fake it indeed. At least I am not aware of any possible way. The only problem is many services like this are available for forex, but I don't know if something similar exists for futures.

Maybe Collective2, but I am not sure how to attach it to the trading platform in order to automatically show every trade and correctly place/change orders.

 

[cornix]

Quote from TheMagican:

With the 20 cars in DAX there are days where $100K a day is possible.

You seriously day trade 20 DAX contracts at a clip? I tried that vehicle, but it's wild and very thin, even worse than CL, which is close to be untradable on 20 cars, with my style, which is breakouts mostly at least.

I would really be stressed to day trade 20 DAX contracts as it would be waiting for an accident to happen.

Not to say that's impossible though.

 

[cornix]

Quote from TheMagican:

Xspurt,$10K to million seems doable at that volatility level as now,but what fi it`s gone?Market can go flat for months any moment,then what?Or what are you students trading in particular?With Japanese Yen it could be possible, though...Just curious on how do you forecast volatility within a year time span?

VIX is as shitty low as it was in 2007... what volatility are you talking about?

 

[cornix]

Quote from marketsurfer:


PS-- Cornix evidence made no sense to me since it came out of thin air--- in other words he MAY have just picked a string of 50 solid trades. Whenever he wants to start again, i am all ears. surf

How could it be picked if I started that public record almost immediately after you challenged me? There are a few guys here @ ET, who saw that record accumulating over time, because before ET, I published it at my own place. The same place where I post NQ calls nearly every day and Euro calls from time to time.

If we find a way to automatically show futures trades somewhere like Collective2 I could do that no doubts.

No statements, because it doesn't convince anyone anyway. I know too well it can be photoshopped etc. 3rd party verified trading history of live calls can't be so it's about the only 100% legit proof in my view.