Surf's Special Situation Journal

TheMagican · Mar 25, 2013

Quote from NoDoji:

Yeah, I also was accused of being one of those snake oil selling cowards, being a shill for [enter name of author/vendor here], and obviously hiding something behind my "carefully crafted online persona as an expert BSD trader" (Surf's words), because if my TA-based trading was so great, why wasn't I proving it in the friendly ET combine competition last fall, and my reply was that I had nothing to prove and no reason to give up $50K of potential profit during that time. And folks were all over me for even insinuating that it was possible to generate $50K of profit over 10 days of TA-based trading.

Can you prove you can make $50K in 10 days?

Surf is one of the few kind and polite folks on the board,btw.So is NoDoji

marketsurfer · Mar 25, 2013

I know ( based on knowing 100's of traders) chart based TA is total garbage regardless of these continual nonsense claims. I have never met one successful chart based trader. The burden of proof is on them regardless of the written gymnastics. You can't throw it back into the skeptics lap. Post a couple statements--- heck even vendor king Tim Sykes posts real statements. What's wrong? surf

marketsurfer · Mar 25, 2013

Quote from TheMagican:

Can you prove you can make $50K in 10 days?

Surf is one of the few kind and polite folks on the board,btw.So is NoDoji

Thanks. She won't even post several months of statements. These Chartees have a mutual mental adoration society going on. What a cult based on faith and claims. Prove me wrong chart readers.

Ol' Yella · Mar 25, 2013

I think the Combine is the perfect venue for any challenges...

the infrastructure and 3rd party oversight is in place so no one can fake anything or wiggle out of anything at the last minute

just look at the Hershey public record thread... it's already a joke

you can't do things like this in a forum or on an honor system

you need an unbiased 3rd party overseeing everything so that no one can cry foul afterwards

R. Raskolnikov · Mar 25, 2013

User Cornix provided over 50 trades via 3rd party verification and the OP scoffed at them. He just doesn't want any proof of TA working. Heck, he said he doesn't believe in TA a couple posts ago. He doesn't WANT to be proven wrong.

Quote from Ol' Yella:

you need an unbiased 3rd party overseeing everything so that no one can cry foul afterwards

marketsurfer · Mar 25, 2013

Quote from Ol' Yella:

I think the Combine is the perfect venue for any challenges...

the infrastructure and 3rd party oversight is in place so no one can fake anything or wiggle out of anything at the last minute

just look at the Hershey public record thread... it's already a joke

you can't do things like this in a forum or on an honor system

you need an unbiased 3rd party overseeing everything so that no one can cry foul afterwards

Thanks. But they refuse to do it. Real statements is the next best thing , but so far the empty suits have failed to produce. Watch them turn the request around again. LOL!

R. Raskolnikov · Mar 25, 2013

User Xspurt said he would provide those statements against yours. What's wrong?

Quote from marketsurfer:

I know ( based on knowing 100's of traders) chart based TA is total garbage regardless of these continual nonsense claims. I have never met one successful chart based trader. The burden of proof is on them regardless of the written gymnastics. You can't throw it back into the skeptics lap. Post a couple statements--- heck even vendor king Tim Sykes posts real statements. What's wrong? surf

marketsurfer · Mar 25, 2013

Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

User Cornix provided over 50 trades via 3rd party verification and the OP scoffed at them. He just doesn't want any proof of TA working. Heck, he said he doesn't believe in TA a couple posts ago. He doesn't WANT to be proven wrong.

50 trades? What's that about 3 hours worth? How about August, sept oct statements to avoid cherry picken.

TheMagican · Mar 25, 2013

Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

User Cornix provided over 50 trades via 3rd party verification and ...blah...

Can`t be serious.User Cornix admitted personally,that he made about $1K or so per month.If that what you are all here standing for,then,ok,i can agree this kind of TA is valid.

marketsurfer · Mar 25, 2013

Quote from R. Raskolnikov:

User Xspurt said he would provide those statements against yours. What's wrong?

LOL. Why against mine? Why? That's a cop out. SHow me one time I made any challenges ---I have zero to prove.