Quote from Ol' Yella:
Sadly, indextrader7 only serves to prove Surf's points. He seems like a nice guy, well intentioned and very hard working, but thusfar trading has not worked out for him. He has posted about his results on another site since leaving ET.
He tried to start a CTA last year and lost double digits the first month, and his business partner quit and told the clients to take their funds out. Since then he has been trying to pass a Combine but has been unsuccessful after 3 or 4 tries.
I am assuming the videos posted here last year are sim account, but am not sure. In one of the early videos he did say he was on sim but not sure if he stayed there.
It's the same story you see over and over again on forums--- big dreams that are never realized. Wish it wasn't so.
Thanks Ol' Yella,
First, as stated before, there does exist traders that posted verification of their profitable trading while using TA. I've seen such with my own two eyes via indextrader7 and several others. surf has stated a few times here at ET such has never occurred here when I knew for fact such had occurred.
Only issue is that these threads are "short lived" and there's very little interest in such threads. Heck, even surf himself stated he's been a long time member here at ET and didn't even know such a thread had existed.
Now getting back to indextrader7, I don't think most are trying to be CTA. He never mentioned such doing the several weeks I watched him trade. Yet, I do know he
suddenly disappeared from his live webcasts with no explanations. However, one of the last days I do remember he said he was going to do something
new with no explanation. Yeah, he did show up at another forum but said trading wasn't for him and I didn't bother to find out what changed from the live webcast to him shutting down.
Simply, I do believe you Ol' Yella. Like I told someone else that was profitable here at ET and was marketing his profitable trading record with broker contact info as verification so that he can manage the money of family/friends prior to soliciting bigger fish...
Why bother with CTA stuff when you have something currently working for you as a profitable retail trader. Unfortunately, he too went belly up after starting a fund.
By the way, in the hindsight recaps...he did say it was simulator but he had planned to go live with real money and would do "live webcast" of his real money trading...that's when I showed up to watch him do live trading and he was profitable even though I felt he seem to get down on himself heavily during losing trades.
Hopefully, indextrader7 will get back to what was working well for him.
Yeah, now that I think more about it. It does seem like a common theme. Profitable trading gets too big for some folks and they then decide to start a fund.