consistency is always key to me... i always try to find out which "cook" did the steaks when I am there for that reason...
overall, I care more about meat quality and taste, and the sides with those steaks.... service... while important, not a deal breaker for me, ... I usually just order my steak, I pick the wine i want that is decent and dont let them decant it... wine selection is not always the best, and a lot of the wines they have are always over priced... you can tell right away when the person doing the service sucks or is great, and just adjust based on that... best service I've ever had was this french place @ 51st and 6th... I forget the name now... amazing service, and good selection of rum and wine...
anyhow, when i want a great bottle of wine, along with great steak, i just grill it at home and open a wine from my little cellar... like today, awesome weather for grilling... which I will do in a little while..
overall, I care more about meat quality and taste, and the sides with those steaks.... service... while important, not a deal breaker for me, ... I usually just order my steak, I pick the wine i want that is decent and dont let them decant it... wine selection is not always the best, and a lot of the wines they have are always over priced... you can tell right away when the person doing the service sucks or is great, and just adjust based on that... best service I've ever had was this french place @ 51st and 6th... I forget the name now... amazing service, and good selection of rum and wine...
anyhow, when i want a great bottle of wine, along with great steak, i just grill it at home and open a wine from my little cellar... like today, awesome weather for grilling... which I will do in a little while..
Quote from R. Raskolnikov:
I agree with you on the consistency factor. I've only been to Sparks once but the steak I had (Prime Strip) was sublime. Of course, next time I go it may not be as consistent. I've only been to Wolfgangs twice but it's been top notch each time. Went to Porterhouse last year and just thought it was so/so. Ordered a bottle of Bordeaux from 98 and the waiter poured the whole thing into the decanter, paying no mind to separating the sediment. That ticked me off, since the bottom 1/5 of the decanter was undrinkable. I thought the steak was just average as well.
Ironically I've never been to Lugers but I hear that it's overrated. Service being the number one complaint. I guess when you are ranked so highly for steak quality, the wait staff doesn't feel compelled to give good service. I want to go at least once to try the porter house though.
