Could be. This is his idol and mentor:
http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2007/10/15/the-blow-up-artist
Sure, Vic N is a smart guy and still wealthy. Doesn't mean he's a great trader, I guess. Not sure how his investors did, hopefully he made them whole...
Excerpt from that article:
"Even by Niederhoffer’s generous standards, going short a billion dollars of stock futures was a large bet, but it worked out well. Not long after the markets reopened on Monday, the bond yield climbed to five per cent, and stocks and stock futures tumbled. On Wednesday, the morning of my visit, shortly after the opening bell sounded on Wall Street, Niederhoffer repurchased the futures he had sold, making more than five million dollars."
So... he shorts 1 bln and only make 0.5% on it.... hmm... So to me, if you're that determined and short that much on the Thursday or Friday and hold it over the weekend... to only to get 0.5% out of it... I can't help but shaking my head to be honest...
EDIT: No, it seems VN and I are on the same line on this...
Next paragraph:
"He didn’t look pleased, though. During the morning, stocks had continued to fall, and he knew that if he had waited he could have made an even bigger profit. He says that in twenty-eight years as a professional investor he hasn’t had a single truly satisfactory trading day. At eleven o’clock, the Dow Jones Industrial Average had slipped about a hundred points and the S. & P. 500 Index was down about thirteen points. Niederhoffer stared morosely at his Bloomberg screens. “The score doesn’t look good,” he muttered."