I understand. And agree. Generally, as concerns life. But in trading price is an absolute. Nothing else matters. What it does, how it does it, where it goes is all that means anything. The "why" doesn't matter one bit. And most of the time cannot be known accurately. Just too many variables. A fund trader whose wife had mucho dinero in the fund could be giving him hell so he sells to move price down. Personal vendetta. Prices drop . Wife sells out. Madder than a hornet on a summer day. Threatens divorce. Trader ..under breath.. says "hurry get paperwork up". Or surf wants to buy a 30 million dollar home. Sell 30 million worth of emini position. Price plunge...buys home..goes long in emini prices rises back up...surf enjoying new home..plus making more money..surf's wife grinning from ear to ear.Although I agree that price is paramount, I don't like to speak in absolutes. Just because I don't rely on fundamentals does not mean that someone else can't do a better job of it than I can. But, indeed, price is the final arbiter.
As for TA, while I use the most basic of price action in my own trading, I do agree with those who say that much of what passes for TA is crap. I'm just careful not to throw the baby out with the bathwater.
