the actual standards are real low here. surf could make calls and have zero haters if he was similar to ES journal in the seriousness. when he lies, and breaks normal trading entry, exit posting protocol in the name of his experiment; it insults every trader's ethics.
in doing so some people are driven to post ; most do not and they are the better people for it. i feel so dirty.
I agree. If he was consistent and honest, he would get a lot more respect. But he would rather be a circus clown.