Stupid PhD

[Sig]

In current markets state for many industries I would be very skeptical to get any advices which are "life matters" from PhD, it's reminds me lot of useless people with MBA diplom or something like that. All you need to do is get practice, and it's just something to add to your experience, not should be something like I am PhD/MBA, pay me at least $5k+ per month

You don't "get practice" doing an M&A or programming low latency embedded programming or managing other people's money without having proven you have the intellectual horsepower and willingness to dedicate yourself to that pursuit. A PhD or MBA are convenient signaling of that ability. And you need look no further than this site to see that in fact folks with MBA's and PhDs do understand important concepts about economics and markets that random jackasses off the street with "practice" or "street smarts" or "common sense" or whatever anti-intellectual label you want to use just don't have. Not only don't they understand the concepts, they don't even enough to know what they don't know about them. So no, PhDs and MBAs can't demand a salary (I sure hope it's a hell of a lot more than $5K a month, by the way!) simply because they have the degree, but it's pretty tough to demand that salary without one. It's a necessary but not sufficient condition, to put it in PhD speak.

 

[ETJ]

Or another way to look at it is the Berlin Wall effect - the East Minted too many PhDs.

 

[ironchef]

You don't "get practice" doing an M&A or programming low latency embedded programming or managing other people's money without having proven you have the intellectual horsepower and willingness to dedicate yourself to that pursuit. A PhD or MBA are convenient signaling of that ability. And you need look no further than this site to see that in fact folks with MBA's and PhDs do understand important concepts about economics and markets that random jackasses off the street with "practice" or "street smarts" or "common sense" or whatever anti-intellectual label you want to use just don't have. Not only don't they understand the concepts, they don't even enough to know what they don't know about them. So no, PhDs and MBAs can't demand a salary (I sure hope it's a hell of a lot more than $5K a month, by the way!) simply because they have the degree, but it's pretty tough to demand that salary without one. It's a necessary but not sufficient condition, to put it in PhD speak.

How do I find someone on ET with a PhD or MBA? I finished my class on Excel VBA Programming (Coursera), trying out a few calculations and have a few questions.

 

[GRULSTMRNN]

You don't need anyone with a PhD, just ask your questions. PM me if you like, I try to help. But I remember you asked about Monte Carlo simulations in another thread. I recommended you to drop Excel/VBA and instead pick up Python/R. Both have ready made packages where you just feed your source data in, parameterize your equations and the rest of the calculations, statistics, and graphs are done by the Python/R packages.

How do I find someone on ET with a PhD or MBA? I finished my class on Excel VBA Programming (Coursera), trying out a few calculations and have a few questions.

 

[ironchef]

You don't need anyone with a PhD, just ask your questions. PM me if you like, I try to help. But I remember you asked about Monte Carlo simulations in another thread. I recommended you to drop Excel/VBA and instead pick up Python/R. Both have ready made packages where you just feed your source data in, parameterize your equations and the rest of the calculations, statistics, and graphs are done by the Python/R packages.

Thanks.