Study Shows Quarantines/Lockdowns Dont Have an effect on Covid-19 spreading

[Market_Diver]

Who cares about Covid?
Accidents, seasonal flu and other diseases killed more people. Do we have to shut the country down too?

Rudy Giuliani, considerably a physically weak man survived Covid.

 

[jem]

1. This study... showed a Maine Supervised Quarantine did not prevent infections better than no quarantine. .... Conclusion gwBe-lying 100 percent .

2. They tested the recruits before putting them into quarantine.

Therefore... I do not see what you are talking about regarding introducing Covid into their population.

Note... this was a Marine Supervised quarantine. Probably far better than 99.9 percent of our self - shelter in places.

3. You don't comprehend studies very well.
It started with De Prado in which your conclusion was the exactly opposite of the Abstract.
It continued with the CDC mask study which you kept denying what the data clearly showed.

Its apparent you don't understand this one either. While its limited... it does show quarantines similar to the our crappy shelter in place type quarantines may not be effective at all.

It seems if you really want to prevent infections... the high risk need to isolate from others.

Once again this study has nothing to do with lockdowns and quarantines not working.

This study is about transmission of COVID across a collocated isolated group of individuals once COVID is introduced into their population. Similar to COVID spreading on a cruise ship but in this case in a military base setting.

Anyone claiming that this study proves that lockdowns and quarantines do not work is bonkers.

 

[Wallet]

1. This study... showed a Maine Supervised Quarantine did not prevent infections any better than no quarantine. .... gwBe-lying 100 percent .

2. They tested the recruits before putting them into quarantine. I do not see what you are talking about regarding introducing Covid into their population. This was a Marine Supervised quarantine. Probably far better than 99.9 percent of our self - shelter in places.

3. You clearly don't comprehend studies. The majority of the important studies we have discussed you have gotten 100% wrong. It started with De Prado in which you conclusion was the exactly opposite of the Abstract. It continued with the CDC mask study.

You are the Covid moron. Nobody says this study proves quarantines don't work. It does challenge their efficacy however. And it you think it through... I think we can conclude our govt should be telling the high risk they have to better protect themselves from family members and that old folks homes need to step up their vigilance even more.

Anything that doesn’t follow the official Debbie Downer narrative is dismissed and ridiculed, both content and author, regardless of fact.

 

[jem]

Correct..
I thought he was doing it for money.

But... I wonder if he may have some sort of clinical condition because he seems to lose his ability to process information.

Anything that doesn’t follow the official Debbie Downer narrative is dismissed and ridiculed, both content and author, regardless of fact.

 

[wildchild]

Once again this study has nothing to do with lockdowns and quarantines not working.

Actually, it says precisely that.

 

[Wallet]

Correct..
I thought he was doing it for money.

But... I wonder if he may have some sort of clinical condition because he seems to lose his ability to process information.

I think you’re correct on both parts.