Quote from drsteph:
Now, in fairness, while I commend the writer on their ability to defer gratification, you need to think about this -
Option #1 - purchase a $300 27" regular TV, use it for 3 years, and throw it away. Then, when you have "made it" , buy a $1000 HDTV flatscreen.
Option #2 - purchase a $600 HDTV LCD 27" TV, use it for 6-9 years, and then purchase the $1000 upgrade TV. Finance the $300 extra on a credit card at 15% interest for a year for $45 in interest. Total cost $645.
I would argue that option #2 is actually more cost effective, even thought the initial outlay is slightly more expensive. However, at the end of 3 years you have spent $1300 with option #1 and $645 with option #2. Since you are starting out, option #2 actually makes more sense. Of course, you need to be disciplined in your purchases and make good decisions.
I remember when my sister bought a $300 Coach purse while in college. While I wondered what she was thinking, she tried to justify it to me as an"investment." I laughed to myself and thought about how anyone could consider a consumer good consumable as an "investment." Particularly one that is likely to be stylish, and require replacement in 2-3 years. By the way, she leads a high-consumption lifestyle and I don't let her advise me on my portfolio.
You have a good point regarding the choice of TVs, though I also deliberately exaggerated the high-end example somewhat. My point was mostly that many people seem to live far, far beyond their means, whether we're talking about TVs, cars or toasters (my girlfriend told me about something she saw on Oprah where people were buying $2,000 toasters...).
I've actually been considering buying a low-end HDTV instead of a traditional tube TV, but I should say that I've been thoroughly unimpressed with the majority of lower end LCD TVs that I've seen. The image quality on some of the cheaper LCD TVs is just terrible in my opinion, I haven't seen anything going for less than $1300 CND or so that piqued my interest.