Quote from Tom1am:
Thanks for responding
First off, I do agree the best alternative would have been to do nothing. ONLY IF BEARISH. NOT if BULLISH.
I tried to post this on Friday Am and it never got posted till the weekend. I bought back the July on Friday for a $498 loss and sold the Jan 10 for $1599 (2 contracts)
Suggestion. Don't speak of total dollars. We need to know per spread numbers. I though you sold the spread for $7, when it was obviously only half that amount.
Mark, Are you referring me to alternative strategies??
No. But when you decide to 'roll' a position, you can choose from among a variety of options to sell.
I am working with an IRA and am not approved for spreads, so actually I am not unhappy with a max gain of 7% and a lower break even between now and the new expiry,
7% is a good gain. Period. If you like your new position, then rolling was a good idea. I was merely telling you that bearish traders would have waited to roll. This is not a big deal.
however if DIA drops enough may buy back the jan calls at hopefully a gain and use the range to determine a new strategy, which has worked very well for me over tha past several months..I just got stuck this time. I am looking forward to reading your books.
If you repurchase the Jan calls 'at a gain' you may not have any gain at all. The calls are only one part of the position. If the underlying declines by more than the profit in the option, the position has a loss over the given period of time.
I don't believe you 'got stuck' this time. As Richard pointed out, most investors love to have the best of all worlds: see the options expire worthless and keep the stock. But, they want the stock right at the strike.
That's not going to happen frequently enough to matter. When I write a covered call, IMHO, the best result is for the stock to rally sharply and I earn the maximum profit that covered call writing allows. Obviously, this is not an opinion shared by everyone.
Thanks for the comment about the books. I love to sell books as much as anyone, but the truth is: The Rookie's Guide is much more complete than the others and if you read that, there is almost nothing important that you will miss. So save some money and only get the latest of the three books.
Take care and thank you all very much for posting