Quote from alannorthcott:
I agree, while you can leverage your money in a way that seems attractive, if you don't get it right, that leverage wipes you out quickly.
You can also put single stock futures, which only came out in 2002, in with options - I recently wrote a single stock futures course for Insight Support in London, England, and that involved me preparing some comparison tables of the different financial instruments.
Of course, futures are even more dangerous for the beginner - at least with options you get the option, and just lose your stake. With futures you're committed to the whole ride down if you are asleep at the wheel.
For someone who wrote a book, that seems like a pretty short answer, lol. If this is the real Alan Northcott, I wanted to say I like your book on short term trading. As a matter of fact, I wanted to buy a copy for several of my family members at x-mas. It's a pretty complete introduction on trading.
I haven't had the time to read the whole thread but if this is a discussion on whether a beginner should trade futures or not, there are comparisons on forex and futures etc in Mastering the Trade by John Carter. He says they can close out your account in Forex before you could lose your house. He wrote that because of slippage in futures, there's only like $3 difference in commissions between forex and futures.
If I even wanted to consider trading futures it would be because when you want to short a stock and no shares are available to short, your trade is cancelled. However, the money management part of it is kind of tricky. You can only risk small amounts in futures.
I just finished reading a bunch of books on trading and I spent time comparing trade setups in different books and I can tell you I want to start with paper trading. Then I want to do some trading with small amounts of money with lots of paper trading on the side. And this is coming from someone who already has experience and already read more than 3 dozen books on trading.
My difficulty of course in the past came from the fact I could not make up my mind on what kind of trading style I wanted to settle on. I figured if I traded for the experience, I might eventually make up my mind. I finally did although I think I should have risked less.
One thing I did figure out about options is this: the bid-ask spread was a "psychological block" for me. It prevented me from taking a loss when I should have or even taken a profit when I should have because I kept on thinking about the slippage.
My plan now is to start with small amounts of money in stocks with no leverage. Then add some leverage on the first day of trading after some time with positive results. Then I might venture into Forex in several months but only if my results are positive and that means I would totally skip options this time.
I might be tempted to trade options with small amounts of money later on. As a matter of fact, I thought about using a reward system where I would only trade an option with profits from my trades. However, I might have to aim for large moves which means larger time frames but that means more time decay. And if it's shorter term, welll, I might hesitate in even taking a profit because of the slippage. The options experience was a little "weird" for me.
I also wanted to add that I found the book by John Carter is excellent except I did not find his trade setups appealing. And Forex is still a little bit âthe Wild Westâ. You can read about that in Getting Started in Currency Trading. Also, if anyone is wondering, the trading style I finally settled upon is based on ideas by Oliver Velez.