Quote from polpolik:
I agree with the first post, the bears are in for a rude awakening in October. Despite the bearish overtone this year and high oil prices, the market has held up pretty well.
My personal opinion is that oil prices will begin to decline as refineries come back up and the continued slowdown of oil consumption in China.
We'll know when october comes, I suppose.
I doubt we'll see a full recovery of the oil industry in this country anytime soon. It will take some time to rebuild the refineries and get the drills floating in the Gulf back up. I think we'll see quite a fall in oil on Tuesday given the post-market SPR news. I really think we're at an intermediate top in oil.
However, I also don't see oil dropping a whole lot. Though I feel there is excess fear built into prices now, there are still plenty of reasons to fear supplies. Oil will remain high, and this almost has to impact US industry.
One thing I don't see people discussing much right now is the extreme possibility of a "stagflation" environment. Most economists in this country are obsessed with the core CPI. I think this is royally stupid. The real prices paid by consumers is increasing rapidly. Perhaps many goods, such as electronics, are relatively stable. But Joe Consumer is going to buy far fewer of these items when it costs hime $10 more this month than last to drive his SUV to Best Buy to get it. I told my wife to stop driving to the suburbs for groceries last week because the cost of buying the gas to get there and back will negate the price savings. People are really forgetting the impact transportation has on pricing and consumption.
Think of the similarities to the 1970's. Oil and gas are very expensive. Perhaps we are not at 1970-levels, but I've seen the lines at the pump growing. The economy is slowing down. Prices are increasing, but typical wages are not increasing as fast. I see most people falling into the trap of wage-based inflation, when what we are seeing is cost-push inflation (just as in the 1970's; the reason why recovery was tough in that period is because economic policy-makers did not recognize the cost-push inflation).
Input inflation takes time to translate to CPI inflation. As the prices of transportation and produciton of goods increases. If a good is costing 10% more to produce today, the consumer may not see that product increase in price for another couple of months, as the product still needs to reach the end retailer and consumer.
Economics changes usually require a catalyst event. I think Katrina may be that event. The shocks to the insurance industry, as well as the surge in oil prices, could create a 1970's style recession.
As for the markets, I don't think we're necessarily going to test the lows from a couple of years ago. But I would expect to see a sizeable dip over the next few months. The oil surge could be felt around the Christmas season, and that would hurt the sales numbers that the Street expects to see during that season. The housing market could get hurt pretty bad in many areas if we do see some sizable inflation, as rates would increase for those with ARMs (it has already increased sizeably for many people).
But of course this is only my opinion. I'm no prophet. I just see this as the path of least resistence over the next few months, and the parellels to the previous stagflation era are quite startling. Lets see what the next consumer numbers look like. If this shock hasn't impacted things much then I guess we'll know I'm wrong.