Originally posted by Traden4Alpha
What I HATE HATE HATE HATEabout tax issues is that NOBODY knows the answer to so many questions, not even the IRS --
Traden4 - I'm guessing you know this, but in case you don't, any taxpayer can request an opinion letter from the IRS on how to treat a particular issue. There are certain legal safe-harbor-type effects to relying on an opinion letter, but the precise legal ramifications are beyond my knowledge.
btw, if you think individual taxation is complicated, you should check out federal corporate, and worse, partnership taxation -- partnership tax is unbelievably complicated. A tax professor I know that had been a Congressional staff member, and had actually worked on the code, admitted that there are parts of subchapter K he can't understand, lol. The upside is that according to him, the partnership audit rate is very low mostly because there are so few IRS auditors that actually understand it themselves...
my personal opinion on the flat tax is that we'll never see one because if you collected all the provisions into a single number, and that number accounted for the huge progressivity in the current system, the overall effective rate would be astronomical - much higher than projections I've heard.
As for complexity, a great deal of the success of the code is that the ordinary person can't understand the law, even if they tried (they actually have to pay other people to help them pay the government!). Many see it as a black box calculation that they don't have enough time or desire to understand - it's easier to pay it and avoid the horror of an audit. The complexity, bureaucracy, and resulting fear assist in compliance - if you make it easy to understand, you also make it easier to object to.
about tax issues is that NOBODY knows the answer to so many questions, not even the IRS --
