Quote from optioncoach:
This whole hedge fund v. prop shop is a silly argument.
UNless you tell me that a person can get 40:1 overnight.
I think it is up to the individual to determine what is best for them then to make blanket statements that it is silly to start a hedge fund, you should always go prop.
Many traders us 100 to one for longer term strategies, and if it fits their overall plan to do this, they don't mind paying a bit to use it (vs. giving away 80% of their profits).
As I mentioned earlier, we have hedge funds within our organization, and I think that the larger funds are fine but....what is often overlooked...."retail" hedge funds often don't receive interest on short stock, and our traders do, of course.
To reiterate....the borrowing of OPM of a few hundred grand or a couple of million, and calling yourself a hedge fund, is where I take issue. The better traders, who prefer working for themselves, often opt to simply put up $25-$50k of their own money to keep 100%.
I really am not trying to "argue" (I tend to get enough of that result anway around ET, LOL)- but I do see some misunderstanding of just how things "can" work, and yes...I agree that everyone should weigh all the benefits before commiting to any longer term trading venture.
Bright traders certainly do a lot more than simple daytrading, and always have.....I've even had people ask me about that..."don't I have to go home flat everyday?" - of course not, how the heck can you trade M&A and pairs and other market neurtral stragegies by going home flat everday?
Anyway, when all is said and done, all of us traders have to make money in the long run, so let's focus on that and "get along."
All the best,
Don