You're exactly right. Some nut will win by pure chance, just like the lottery. There is no skill involved. Now if they said "let's see who has the best risk-adjusted return", that would be entirely different.
Quote from EqtTrdr:
oh man.. forget it...
some soccer mom buying a .52 stock going to win and CNBC will pump on the show.."see everyone can trade.. no need to work"
forget this... ain't for me